You are in: eMedicine Specialties > Radiology > MUSCULOSKELETAL Shoulder, Rotator Cuff Injury (MRI)Article Last Updated: May 22, 2007AUTHOR AND EDITOR INFORMATIONAuthor: Michael Tuite, MD, Director of Musculoskeletal Radiology, Professor, Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin Hospital Michael Tuite is a member of the following medical societies: American College of Radiology, American Roentgen Ray Society, International Skeletal Society, Radiological Society of North America, and Society of Skeletal Radiology Coauthor(s): Matthew F Sanford, MD, Fellow in Musculoskeletal Radiology, Department of Radiology, University of Wisconsin Medical School Editors: David S Levey, MD, PhD, Musculoskeletal Radiologist, Department of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Radsource, LLC; Bernard D Coombs, MB, ChB, PhD, Consulting Staff, Department of Specialist Rehabilitation Services, Hutt Valley District Health Board, New Zealand; Lynne S Steinbach, MD, Chief of Musculoskeletal Radiology, Professor, Department of Radiology, University of California at San Francisco; Robert M Krasny, MD, Consulting Staff, Department of Radiology, The Angeles Clinic and Research Institute; Felix S Chew, MD, MBA, EdM, Professor, Department of Radiology, Vice Chairman for Radiology Informatics, Section Head of Musculoskeletal Radiology, University of Washington Author and Editor Disclosure Synonyms and related keywords: rotator cuff impingement, rotator cuff tear, RCT, rim-rent tear INTRODUCTIONBackgroundShoulder pain is a common complaint by patients during physician visits, and it can be due to a variety of causes. The major cause of shoulder pain in patients older than 40 years is rotator cuff impingement and tears. With the development of new arthroscopic techniques for treating rotator cuff disorders, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has played an increasingly important role as a noninvasive test for determining which patients may benefit from surgery. For excellent patient education resources, visit eMedicine's Breaks, Fractures, and Dislocations Center. Also, see eMedicine's patient education articles, Shoulder Dislocation, Shoulder Separation, and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI). PathophysiologyThe 2 potential etiologies of rotator cuff pain are mechanical causes, such as a flap of tendon that catches under the acromion, and biologic causes, such as synovitis. Although the rotator cuff is innervated, the subacromial bursa has 20 times the number of free nerve endings compared with the rotator cuff tendon. Compression of the subacromial bursa or catching of redundant synovium may cause much of the pain in patients with rotator cuff impingement. Rotator Cuff Tears There are 3 main mechanisms involved in the development of RCTs:
Charles Neer was the first to popularize the theory that RCTs in older patients were primarily the result of extrinsic compression by the anterior acromion process, coracoacromial ligament, and acromioclavicular joint1—the structures that make up the coracoacromial arch (see Image 1). Until then, most surgical procedures had only involved repairing the rotator cuff, without decompressing the roof of the arch; unfortunately, these procedures often failed to provide patients with long-term pain relief. Neer's technique of decompression of the coracoacromial arch along with repair of the rotator cuff was extremely successful, with a 90% success rate reported by most surgeons.2 However, surgeons have since modified portions of Neer's original theory. For example, they now believe that most anterior subacromial spurs are coracoacromial ligament enthesophytes caused by chronic impingement. Yet over 3 decades after Neer's study, decompression of the arch with rotator cuff repair remains the standard surgical treatment of rotator cuff impingement pain and RCTs. Despite the surgical success of subacromial decompression, several authors have stressed the role of intrinsic tendon degeneration as the main etiology in the development of RCTs. Rathburn and Macnab demonstrated a zone of relative hypovascularity in the supraspinatus tendon approximately 1 cm from the insertion onto the greater tuberosity, which corresponded with the critical zone where most RCTs were noted to occur.3 Rothman and Parke had previously shown that degeneration occurred in these same hypovascular areas of the cuff.4 Lohr and Uhthoff5 and Clark and Harryman6 took this a step further, noting that the articular side of the rotator cuff has a sparse blood supply relative to the bursal surface. Multiple studies have revealed that most partial-thickness tears of the rotator cuff involve the articular surface, which would be unusual if chronic impingement from a hooked acromion or acromioclavicular joint osteophyte was the dominant cause of the tears. In addition, Nakajima et al7 and Lee et al8 showed that although the bursal surface bundles are able to elongate with a tensile load, the articular-surface fibers do not stretch and therefore tear more easily. Kjellin et al reported that partial RCTs originated from areas of advanced degeneration and that there was no vascular ingrowth around the tears to indicate active inflammation.9 Many authors now believe that chronic tendon overload leads to degeneration in the hypovascular region of the rotator cuff because of poor healing and that these areas can eventually progress to RCT. Burkhart has refined this theory with 2 observations: he noted that this hypovascular region does not involve the anterior and posterior edges of the supraspinatus tendon and that a "cable" of thicker, better-perfused tissue connects these edges more medially (see Image 2).10 This thickened tendon "cable" separates the musculotendinous junction from a crescent-shaped area of the lateral aspect of the supraspinatus tendon, where most RCTs occur. Another cause of RCTs is internal, or posterosuperior, impingement. During abduction and external rotation, the undersurface of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus tendons may normally lie between the greater tuberosity and the posterosuperior glenoid. In the throwing athlete, this normal physiologic phenomenon may result in pathologic internal impingement pain. Internal impingement was first described in the early 1990s by arthroscopists. At arthroscopy, it was noted that articular-surface posterior cuff abnormalities, posterosuperior labral irregularity, and apposition of the humeral head and labrum existed in overhead-throwing athletes who had shoulder pain. The radiology literature has confirmed that the following findings are observed in athletes with clinically diagnosed internal impingement:
Identification of this constellation of findings by MRI should alert the radiologist and arthroscopist to the diagnosis of internal impingement. The mechanism from which internal impingement arises is uncertain. One theory states that the pain and internal impingement tears are due to the repetitive impaction against the rotator cuff and labrum. Another theory purports that reactive thickening of the posteroinferior capsule results from shoulder deceleration during the throwing motion. This capsular thickening triggers a cascade of abnormal shoulder biomechanics that alters the contact point between the humerus and glenoid, thereby stretching the anterior capsule and resulting in laxity. This acquired pathologic laxity of the shoulder may alter stabilization of the humeral head within the glenoid during the late cocking or early acceleration phase of throwing. Thickening of the posteroinferior capsule is thought to decrease the ability of the glenohumeral joint to internally rotate, with ensuing compensatory increased external rotation. The exaggerated external rotation and the altered humeral head contact point cause the rotator cuff and posterosuperior labrum to be subjected to shearing forces that result in the pathologic changes identified at arthroscopy and on MRI.In 1998, Tuite et al identified the fact that patients with clinically diagnosed internal impingement of the rotator cuff had thickening of the posteroinferior labrocapsular complex as well as a more shallow posterior capsular recess.11 These observations may prove useful in identifying patients who are at risk for internal impingement; diagnosis by MRI is helpful in this subset of patients, as nonoperative therapy with selective stretching of the posterior inferior labrum may decrease symptoms. In those in whom conservative measures fail, a posterior capsulotomy may be of benefit. FrequencyUnited StatesShoulder pain is one of the most common reasons patients give for a physician visit, third only to headache and back pain.12 The incidence of rotator cuff disease increases as people age, although RCTs may not always be symptomatic. Sher et al obtained MRI scans for 46 asymptomatic individuals who were older than 60 years and found that 54% had either a partial-thickness or full-thickness RCT.13 Another study found that only 28% of all RCTs are painful and that many full-thickness tears are asymptomatic.14 InternationalSee US Frequency. Mortality/MorbidityAlthough RCTs can be asymptomatic, these injuries can also be quite painful, with many affected patients describing the pain as one that awakens them at night. A functioning rotator cuff is also necessary for many activities of daily living, such as brushing one’s hair. There is significant job-related disability for individuals who have to lift or perform activities at the shoulder level. RaceNo race predilection has been observed. SexA slightly higher incidence of RCTs in men has been reported in cadaver studies, but the difference is not significant. AgeMost RCTs occur in older individuals, although they can also occur in younger individuals who are active in sports that involve overhead movements. Sher et al found the average age of patients with full-thickness tears was greater than that of those with partial-thickness tears.13 Because some patients with chronic RCTs and supraspinatus tendon atrophy are not surgical candidates, the true average age of those in the general population who have a full-thickness tear is probably higher as well. AnatomyThe rotator cuff is made up of tendons from 4 muscles: the supraspinatus, infraspinatus, teres minor, and subscapularis. The tendon fibers of the supraspinatus, infraspinatus, and teres minor blend 1.5 cm from their lateral margins before they insert onto the greater tuberosity, with the bulk of the supraspinatus fibers inserting onto the superior facet of the greater tuberosity, whereas the infraspinatus and teres minor tendon fibers insert along the posterior aspect. The subscapularis tendon inserts independently onto the lesser tuberosity. The rotator cuff interval, or anterior interval, separates the supraspinatus and subscapularis tendons. This gap between the tendons contains the coracohumeral ligament and superior glenohumeral ligament, as well as allows the long head of the biceps tendon to pass from the bicipital groove through the glenohumeral joint before inserting onto the superior glenoid. The supraspinatus tendon is clinically the most important rotator cuff tendon because it is involved, either alone or in combination with 1 or more additional tendons, in 95% of cuff tears.15 The main tendon of the supraspinatus forms within the mid portion of the muscle, but as the supraspinatus courses laterally, the tendon lies progressively more anteriorly within the muscle. The supraspinatus tendon follows the curvature of the superior humeral head and curves caudally to insert onto the superior facet of the greater tuberosity. The supraspinatus tendon is approximately 9-11 mm thick at dissection but usually appears thinner (approximately 6-8 mm) on oblique coronal MRIs in patients who are positioned with the affected arm adducted and the rotator cuff under tension. The rotator cuff tendon is unusual in the body in that it is not surrounded by either a synovial sheath or paratenon. Superficial to the supraspinatus tendon lies the subacromial-subdeltoid bursa, which may contain a thin layer of fluid in asymptomatic individuals. The superior surface of the rotator cuff is often termed the bursal surface. The inferior or more caudal surface of the cuff, termed the deep or articular surface, lies adjacent to the capsule and synovial lining of the glenohumeral joint.Histologically, Clark and Harryman described 5 layers that make up the rotator cuff.6 The 2 layers that form the bursal one third of the tendon contain closely packed, well-organized tendon fibers, as does the layer forming the articular surface of the cuff. In the center of the rotator cuff are 2 layers that contain less-organized fibers mixed with loose connective tissue. On fat-suppressed, T2-weighted MRI, this central third of the tendon can have an intermediate signal intensity in normal individuals, whereas the outer portions of the cuff should show low signal intensity (see Image 3). The histology of the rotator cuff contributes to one of the difficulties of rotator cuff MRI interpretation, the magic-angle effect or angular anisotropy. This effect is an MRI artifact in which normally low-signal structures that are made of organized collagen fibers appear as a higher signal intensity on images that are obtained with a short echo time (TE). The artifact occurs when the long axes of the collagen fibers are oriented at 55° to the main magnetic field. In most high-field MRI scanners, the main magnetic field is oriented along the direction of the bore (the central tunnel where the patient lies). The well-organized collagen fibers in the outer portions of the rotator cuff are organized longitudinally; therefore, these normally low-signal fibers have increased signal intensity on short-TE images as the fibers curve and become oriented at the magic angle. Unfortunately, this effect occurs in the region of the critical zone where RCTs and degenerative tendinopathy are prevalent. However, the magic angle’s high signal intensity diminishes with increasing TE; thus, it is not usually a problem on the fat-suppressed, fast spin-echo (FSE), T2-weighted MRIs most radiologists currently use to image the rotator cuff.Clinical DetailsThe classic clinical presentation of rotator cuff impingement pain is a chronic ache in the lateral aspect of the shoulder, aggravated by attempts to abduct the arm and often worse at night. Patients typically have a severely painful arc from 60-120° of abduction and forward flexion. Weakness during abduction or forward flexion also may be present, particularly in patients who have an RCT. Preferred ExaminationConventional MRI with T2-weighted images in both the oblique coronal and oblique sagittal planes is the preferred technique for imaging the rotator cuff. Most authors have found that fat-suppressed, FSE, T2-weighted images are the most accurate for detecting RCTs; a sensitivity of 84-100% and a specificity of at least 77-97% for full-thickness tears can be expected with this pulse sequence.16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21 Although most RCTs can be seen on oblique coronal images, Patten et al reported that oblique sagittal images provide approximately a 10% improvement in accuracy for detecting RCTs, although this was not stastically significant.22 The authors found that oblique sagittal images are especially helpful for identifying tears involving the anterior edge of the supraspinatus (see Images 4a-d). Indirect MR arthrography requires only an intravenous (IV) injection, but this modality has a disadvantage in that it does not distend the joint. As in direct MR arthrography, short scanning time T1-weighted images can be used instead of T2-weighted images. Several authors have shown that compared with conventional MRIs of the rotator cuff, RCTs are better characterized on indirect MR arthrography and there is better correlation with surgical findings. One study reported that 2 radiologists improved their accuracy for detecting RCTs from 67% and 62% with conventional MRI to 92% and 96%, respectively, with indirect MR arthrography.24 Again, use of fat suppression is important, but exercising the joint does not appear to improve accuracy. Despite these studies, MR arthrography has not been as widely accepted for evaluating the rotator cuff as it has been for imaging the glenoid labrum. Direct MR arthrography does improve the depiction of posterior articular-surface partial-thickness tears that are observed in overhead-throwing athletes, particularly if the shoulder is scanned in abduction and external rotation. However, most authors have found that fat-suppressed, FSE, T2-weighted images obtained with a quality shoulder coil are fairly accurate for most RCTs and that conventional MRI is adequate for routine imaging of the rotator cuff. Conventional arthrography was the traditional technique for detecting RCTs. However, arthrography itself does not demonstrate bursal-sided, partial-thickness tears, and it may be difficult at times to determine the size of a tear using this modality. With improvements in computed tomography (CT) scanners, oblique coronal reformatted CT arthrogram images can provide excellent images of the rotator cuff in patients who are unable to undergo an MRI.Limitations of TechniquesMRI is contraindicated in patients who have a cardiac pacemaker, ferromagnetic foreign bodies (particularly in the orbit), and some cochlear implants. Some patients are extremely claustrophobic in high-field-strength MRI scanners, although many of these patients can be scanned in open MRI scanners after administration of a mild sedative. Gadolinium-based contrast agents (gadopentetate dimeglumine [Magnevist], gadobenate dimeglumine [MultiHance], gadodiamide [Omniscan], gadoversetamide [OptiMARK], gadoteridol [ProHance]) have recently been linked to the development of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF) or nephrogenic fibrosing dermopathy (NFD). For more information, see the eMedicine topic Nephrogenic Fibrosing Dermopathy. The disease has occurred in patients with moderate to end-stage renal disease after being given a gadolinium-based contrast agent to enhance MRI or MRA scans. As of late December 2006, the FDA had received reports of 90 such cases. Worldwide, over 200 cases have been reported, according to the FDA. NSF/NFD is a debilitating and sometimes fatal disease. Characteristics include red or dark patches on the skin; burning, itching, swelling, hardening, and tightening of the skin; yellow spots on the whites of the eyes; joint stiffness with trouble moving or straightening the arms, hands, legs, or feet; pain deep in the hip bones or ribs; and muscle weakness. For more information, see the FDA Public Health Advisory or Medscape. DIFFERENTIALSShoulder, Rotator Cuff Injury (Ultrasonography) Other Problems to Be ConsideredInstability with secondary impingement
FindingsFull-thickness tears For many orthopedic surgeons, the main role of shoulder MRI is to detect a full-thickness RCT. The most common appearance of a full-thickness tear is high signal intensity on a T2-weighted image that extends from the articular surface of the rotator cuff to the subacromial-subdeltoid bursa (see Image 2). Rafii et al reported that high signal was observed in approximately 90% of full-thickness tears proven at surgery.25 In chronic RCTs in which the shoulder joint has little or no effusion, the humeral head may be high riding, such that not much high signal is seen at the tear site (see Image 3). Some patients may also develop fibrous thickening of the subacromial-subdeltoid bursa, which can mimic an intact tendon in the absence of an effusion; therefore, it is important to trace a low-signal structure as it passes over the humeral head. Rotator cuff fibers will end at their insertion on the greater tuberosity, whereas fibrous thickening of the bursa will continue deep to the deltoid muscle below the greater tuberosity. In addition, acute RCTs can hemorrhage at the tear site, with the blood mimicking some intact fibers. It is important to distinguish the smoothly curving, low-signal surfaces of the rotator cuff from the disorganized low-signal surfaces of fibrin and other blood products.Most small full-thickness tears arise in the anterior aspect of the supraspinatus tendon in the critical zone (see Images 4-5). Localizing a small full-thickness tear to the rotator cuff crescent may be helpful for the shoulder surgeon, who may then decide to only debride, but not repair, the cuff defect. Although RCTs often begin in the critical zone, resorption of the tendon stump at the greater tuberosity may occur if chronic full-thickness tears are left untreated. Full-thickness avulsion tears of the tendon away from the greater tuberosity are less common. Massive tears often extend posteriorly to involve the infraspinatus tendon or extend anteriorly to tear the anterior interval and subscapularis tendon.If a full-thickness tear is observed, it is important to document whether or not the entire anterior-to-posterior width of the supraspinatus tendon is involved. In RCTs that involve the entire tendon, the tendon edge can retract medial to the glenoid, where it becomes extremely difficult to grasp and to reattach to the greater tuberosity. Long-standing RCTs can also result in the development of muscle atrophy and fatty degeneration that may prevent successful repair. It is important to expeditiously obtain imaging studies in patients who have a possible acute full-thickness, complete-width, supraspinatus tendon tear. If an acute complete supraspinatus tendon tear is identified, surgery is often scheduled within the next several days so that the tendon can be repaired before the development of retraction or atrophy. Partial-thickness tears Partial-thickness tears can be classified as articular, bursal, or intratendinous. Intratendinous tears may be a cause of shoulder pain, but they are not observed at routine arthroscopy and are rarely treated surgically. Articular-surface partial-thickness tears are more common than bursal-surface tears (at an approximately 3:1 incidence rate).26, 27 Many patients with a bursal-surface tear also have an articular-surface tear. The accuracy of MRI for partial-thickness tears is lower than that for full-thickness tears. Although some authors have reported a sensitivity greater than 0.90 for partial-thickness tears, others have reported sensitivities as low as 0.17-0.56.18, 21, 25, 28, 29 Reinus et al were unable to correctly identify the side of the affected rotator cuff (articular vs bursal) in 50% of their patients with a partial-thickness tear.16 One reason for the low accuracy is that a high-signal defect on T2-weighted images is a less common finding in partial-thickness tears than in full-thickness tears; in a study by Rafii et al, this high-signal defect was seen in only 7 of 16 cases of partial-thickness tears.25 Partial-thickness tears often appear on MRI as only an intermediate signal, isointense to muscle, which disrupts the normal low-signal surface of the rotator cuff (see Image 6). Absence of fluid in an RCT on MRI may be from the presence of a poor-quality scar or granulation tissue within the defect, and this can be difficult to distinguish from tendon degeneration or a healed RCT. Partial-thickness tears may also have smooth margins that taper gradually so that the rotator cuff appears to be only somewhat thinned (see Image 7). Although most partial-thickness tears occur in the critical zone of the supraspinatus tendon, some RCTs occur in less common locations. In younger patients, a small articular-surface avulsion-type partial-thickness tear can occur adjacent to the greater tuberosity; this is termed a rim-rent tear (see Image 8). Tears isolated to the infraspinatus tendon occur in 1-7% of patients with RCTs, but these tears are more common in athletes who perform overhead activities.11 MR arthrography in which the patient is positioned with the arm in abduction and external rotation is the best technique for identifying these infraspinatus articular-surface partial-thickness tears, which often are associated with adjacent glenoid labral fraying. Degree of ConfidenceMany studies investigating the use of fat-suppressed, FSE imaging have reported a sensitivity of 84-100% and a specificity of 77-97% for full-thickness tears18, 19, 20, 21; however, the accuracy for partial-thickness tears is lower. MR arthrography may be helpful for better demonstrating articular-surface partial-thickness tears. Angling the oblique coronal or oblique sagittal images to the rotator cuff surface at the suspected tear site can improve the accuracy of conventional MRI. False Positives/NegativesThere are 3 other abnormalities of the rotator cuff that can mimic an RCT: degeneration, tendinopathy, and cuff strain. Rotator cuff degeneration is common in older individuals and appears as an ill-defined area of increased signal on T2-weighted MRIs within the substance of the cuff. All rotator cuffs undergo age-related degeneration in which the normally compact and well-organized collagen fibers are replaced by intermediate-signal myxoid and eosinophilic material. As aging progresses and the rotator cuff is put under repeated stress, small fissures can develop within the cuff substance and appear as thin areas of fluid on MRI. If the MRI contrast and brightness are set too high (ie, windowed too tightly), these fissures can occasionally bloom and appear as a tear that extends to the surface of the cuff (see Image 9). Tendinopathy, occasionally incorrectly termed tendinitis, is a related intratendinous process that is histologically similar to rotator cuff degeneration. Although the term tendinopathy is occasionally used interchangeably with age-related cuff degeneration, some clinicians reserve the term for younger symptomatic patients.As with patellar "tendinitis," tendinopathy is not truly an inflammatory process because there is no edema, vascular invasion, or acute inflammatory cells (see Image 10). Instead, what occurs pathologically is severe mucoid and eosinophilic degeneration with intratendinous clefts, often causing focal tendon swelling and, occasionally, surface fibrillation (see Image 11). If windowed incorrectly during imaging, tendinopathy can also appear to extend to involve the surface of the rotator cuff. Rotator cuff strain after acute trauma has been described as another potential cause of increased intratendinous signal on MRI. This typically occurs in younger patients (< 35 y) who have an associated bone bruise and focal increased signal intensity in the posterior aspect of the supraspinatus tendon, as distinguished from cuff degeneration, which involves a larger area that is centered in the anterior critical zone. Patients with presumed rotator cuff strain as demonstrated on MRI are less likely to require surgery than older patients who develop shoulder pain after acute trauma. In summary, fat-suppressed, FSE, T2-weighted images obtained with a quality shoulder coil are accurate for diagnosing RCTs. False-negative full-thickness tears typically occur when the patient does not have an effusion and when the subdeltoid bursal capsule is thickened. False-negative partial-thickness tears are fairly common, especially for tears that are not very deep. Failure to diagnose partial-thickness tears can be minimized by radiologists carefully inspecting the low-signal surfaces of the rotator cuff and noting whether the low-signal surface layers are disrupted, as well as by use of both intra-articular and IV gadolinium to enhance the conspicuity of these lesions.
Shoulder, Rotator Cuff Injury (MRI) excerpt Article Last Updated: May 22, 2007 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||