You are in: eMedicine Specialties > Obstetrics and Gynecology > Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility Preimplantation Genetic DiagnosisArticle Last Updated: Apr 13, 2005AUTHOR AND EDITOR INFORMATIONAuthor: JJ Marik, MD, Assistant Clinical Professor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of California School of Medicine at Los Angeles; Director, Tyler Medical Clinic JJ Marik is a member of the following medical societies: American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, American Society for Reproductive Medicine, and Association of Professors of Gynecology and Obstetrics Editors: Bryan D Cowan, MD, Professor and Chairman, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Mississippi College of Medicine; Consulting Staff, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Veterans Affairs Medical Center; Medical Director, Wiser Hospital for Women, University of Mississippi Medical Center; Francisco Talavera, PharmD, PhD, Senior Pharmacy Editor, eMedicine; A David Barnes, MD, PhD, MPH, FACOG, Consulting Staff, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Mammoth Hospital, Mammoth Lakes, California, Pioneer Valley Hospital, Salt Lake City, Utah, Warren General Hospital, Warren, Pennsylvania and Mountain West Hospital, Tooele, Utah; Michael E Zevitz, MD, Assistant Professor of Medicine, Finch University of the Health Sciences, The Chicago Medical School; Consulting Staff, Private Practice; Lee P Shulman, MD, Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University; Chief, Division of Reproductive Genetics, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Prentice Women's Hospital, Northwestern Memorial Hospital Author and Editor Disclosure Synonyms and related keywords: PGD, genetic defect, prenatal diagnosis, genetic disease, X-linked disorder, genetic mutation, reproductive medicine, assisted reproduction, AST, inherited diseases, sex-related genetic disorders, birth defect, birth defect prevention, chromosomal disorders, single gene defects, single-gene defects, hemophilia, fragile X syndrome, neuromuscular dystrophy, Rett syndrome, Rett's syndrome, incontinentia pigmenti, pseudohyperparathyroidism, vitamin D-resistant rickets, vitamin D resistant rickets, rickets, cystic fibrosis, Tay-Sachs disease, sickle cell anemia, Huntington disease, Huntington's disease, chromosomal translocation, chromosomal inversion, chromosomal deletion, in vitro fertilization, IVF, amniocentesis, chorionic villus sampling, CVS, intracytoplasmic sperm injection, ICSI, polar body biopsy, blastocyst biopsy, polymerase chain reaction, PCR, fluorescence in situ hybridization, FISH, DNA amplification, comparative genomic hybridization, CGH, interphase conversion INTRODUCTIONPreimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) is a technique used to identify genetic defects in embryos created through in vitro fertilization (IVF) before transferring them into the uterus. Because only unaffected embryos are transferred to the uterus for implantation, PGD provides an alternative to current postconception diagnostic procedures, ie, amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling, which are frequently followed by pregnancy termination if results are unfavorable. PGD is performed in conjunction with IVF and is offered to fertile and infertile couples. History Edwards and Gardner successfully performed the first known embryo biopsy on rabbit embryos in 1968. In humans, PGD was developed in the United Kingdom in the mid 1980s as an alternative to current prenatal diagnoses (Harper, 2001). PGD is presently the only option available for avoiding a high risk of having a child affected with a genetic disease without facing the dilemma of pregnancy termination following unfavorable prenatal diagnosis. In 1989 in London, Handyside and colleagues reported the first unaffected child born following PGD performed for an X-linked disorder. As of May 2001, more than 3000 PGD clinical cycles have been reported. These cycles were performed at more than 40 centers around the world, and almost 700 children have been born, thus demonstrating the reliability and safety of the procedure. PGD is currently available for most known genetic mutations (International Working Group on Preimplantation Genetics, 2001). Since 2001, many more centers have started offering PGD to their patients, unless it is prohibited by the laws of a particular country. Definition PGD combines recent advances in genetics and reproductive medicine. For PGD, the early embryo is examined after IVF for inherited diseases or to determine the sex of the embryo for sex-related genetic disorders. The process starts with a basic IVF. When the embryo is at the 6- to 8-cell stage, 1-2 cells (blastomeres) are removed and sent to the genetic laboratory for diagnosis using either polymerase chain reaction (PCR) or fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) techniques, depending on which disease is being sought. The unaffected embryos are then transferred into the mother's uterus. In certain situations in which the genetic problem is only with the female, a polar body can be removed from the eggs and tested before fertilization. INDICATIONS AND CONDITIONSIndications for PGDPGD is recommended when embryos may be affected by a certain genetic condition. Only healthy and normal embryos are transferred into the mother's uterus, thus preventing adverse outcomes such as miscarriages, pregnancy termination (after positive prenatal diagnosis), or birth defects (physical and/or mental). Primary candidates for PGD include the following:
Conditions diagnosed using PGDPGD should be offered for 3 major groups of disease, including (1) sex-linked disorders, (2) single gene defects, and (3) chromosomal disorders. Sex-linked disorders PGD can be used to determine the sex of an embryo in which the specific genetic defect at a molecular level is unknown, highly variable, or unsuitable for testing on single cells. Sex-linked recessive disorders include hemophilia, fragile X syndrome, most of the neuromuscular dystrophies (currently, >900 neuromuscular dystrophies are known), and hundreds of other diseases. Sex-linked dominant disorders include Rett syndrome, incontinentia pigmenti, pseudohyperparathyroidism, and vitamin D–resistant rickets. X-linked diseases are passed to the child through a mother who is a carrier. They are passed by an abnormal X chromosome and manifest in sons, who do not inherit the normal X chromosome from the father. Affected fathers have sons who are not affected, and their daughters have a 50% risk of being carriers if the mother is healthy. Single gene defects PGD is used to identify single gene defects such as cystic fibrosis, Tay-Sachs disease, sickle cell anemia, and Huntington disease. In such diseases, the molecular abnormality is detectable with molecular techniques using PCR amplification of DNA from a single cell. Although progress has been made, some single gene defects have a wide variety of rare mutations (eg, cystic fibrosis has approximately 1000 known mutations). Only 25 of these mutations are currently routinely tested. Because most of these rare mutations are not routinely tested, a parent without any clinical manifestations of cystic fibrosis could be a carrier. This allows the possibility for a parent carrying a rare mutation gene to be tested as negative but still have the ability to pass on the mutant cystic fibrosis gene. Chromosomal disorders The last group includes chromosomal disorders in which a variety of chromosomal rearrangements, including translocations, inversions, and deletions, can be detected using FISH. Some parents may have never achieved a viable pregnancy without using PGD because previous conceptions resulted in chromosomally unbalanced embryos and were spontaneously miscarried. Aneuploidy and maternal ageThe risk of aneuploidy in children increases as women age. The chromosomes in the egg are less likely to divide properly, leading to an extra or missing chromosome in the embryo (see Table 1). The rate of aneuploidy in embryos is greater than 20% in mothers aged 35-39 years and is nearly 40% in mothers aged 40 years or older. The rate of aneuploidy in children is 0.6-1.4% in mothers aged 35-39 years and is 1.6-10% in mothers older than 40 years. The difference in percentages between affected embryos and live births is due to the fact that an embryo with aneuploidy is less likely to be carried to term and will most likely be miscarried, some even before pregnancy is suspected or confirmed. Therefore, using PGD to determine the chromosomal makeup of embryos increases the chance of a healthy pregnancy and reduces the number of pregnancy losses and affected offspring. One of the most frequent aneuploidies, trisomy (ie, 3 identical chromosomes present in the embryo), is trisomy of chromosome 21, which leads to Down syndrome. This particular abnormality also frequently leads to spontaneous miscarriages, the precise frequency of which is difficult to determine. Thus, the only reliable information is on the frequency of babies born with Down syndrome. An excellent and informative article in the Journal of the American Medical Association (Hook, 1983) includes information on estimating the incidence of trisomy 21/Down syndrome in fetuses at 16 weeks of pregnancy (also see Table 2). Table 1. Chromosomal Abnormalities
Table 2. Frequency of Down Syndrome Per Maternal Age
PGD and sex selection unrelated to diseaseBecause PGD can help determine the sex of the embryo, many couples request PGD for sex selection, which can be motivated by cultural, social, ethnic, psychological, and other reasons such as the simple desire to have children of a preferred sex to achieve a balance among children in a given family or to determine a sex birth order. The use of PGD for sex selection unrelated to disease is controversial and has elicited moral outrage about not implanting normal embryos when they are found to be of an undesired sex. Some people consider this infanticide. Other frequent objections include the danger of sex discrimination, the perpetuation of oppression against females, the ethics of expanding control over nonessential characteristics of offspring, and the relative importance of sex selection when weighed against medical and financial burdens to parents. Much discussion is still necessary to achieve a reasonable consensus and acceptance of PGD for sex selection. Personal, religious, ethical, and moral norms vary among different populations. Personal preferences must be considered and proper respect given to them. PROCESSPGD process using blastomereWorkup Before requesting PGD, candidates should consult a geneticist or genetic counselor to evaluate the risk of transferring their genetic abnormality to their offspring. Tests should be performed to confirm the diagnosis of the affected parent, to pinpoint the genetic change leading to the condition in question, and to ensure that the currently available technology can identify that genetic change in a polar body or a blastomere biopsy sample from a 6- to 8-cell embryo/blastocyst (see Image 1). In vitro fertilization A 16- to 17-gauge needle is typically used for transvaginal aspiration of the follicles under ultrasound control. Vaginal tissue sensitivity is low, whereas ovarian sensitivity is considerably higher. The most sensitive part of the pelvis is the peritoneal lining. Light general anesthesia or conscious sedation with a narcotic and tranquilizer are used, depending on physician and patient preferences. Both are satisfactory for egg retrieval. Patients are kept supine until they are fully awake and all vital signs are stable. They should be discharged to the custody of an adult and are strongly advised to not engage in certain activities, such as driving, for the remainder of the day. The IVF procedure consists of the following steps:
Removal of the single cell Most clinics offering PGD perform biopsy using one of two techniques:
Genetic testingPolymerase chain reaction PCR is used for the diagnosis of single gene defects, including dominant and recessive disorders. PCR, sometimes called DNA amplification, is a technique in which a particular DNA sequence is copied many times in order to facilitate its analysis. PCR rapidly multiplies a single DNA molecule into billions of molecules. The DNA is immersed in a solution containing the DNA polymerase enzyme, unattached nucleotide bases, and primers. The solution is heated to break the bonds between the strands of the DNA. When the solution cools, the primers bind to the separated strands, and the DNA polymerase quickly builds new strands by joining the free nucleotide bases to the primers. By repeating this process, a strand that was formed with one primer binds to the other primer, resulting in a new strand that is specific solely to the desired segment. Further repetitions of the process can produce billions of copies of a small piece of DNA in several hours. PCR is a relatively fast and convenient way to test DNA. The method has been used in a variety of preimplantation genetic testing protocols. However, it requires sufficient amounts of a pure, high-quality sample of DNA, which is sometimes difficult to obtain from a single cell such as a polar body or blastomere. In addition, laboratory contamination and allele dropout are possible complications. Only one cell should be amplified; however, if another cell or piece of DNA enters the tube, it is also amplified. ICSI must be used to minimize this problem and to ensure that no excess sperm are present (paternal contamination) and that all the cumulus cells have been removed (maternal contamination). The laboratory environment must be strictly controlled to avoid the introduction of contaminants to the tested material. The laboratory technicians must be trained extremely well to avoid all types of outside interferences. Allele dropout is the preferential amplification of one allele over another and is mainly a problem for PGD of dominant disorders or when 2 different mutations are carried for a recessive disorder and only one mutation is being analyzed. Each mutation or disease requires a specific PCR test to be developed, which is a time-consuming and expensive process. Fluorescence in situ hybridization FISH is used for the determination of sex for X-linked diseases, chromosomal abnormalities, and for aneuploidy screening. Probes, ie, small pieces of DNA that are a match for the chromosomes being analyzed, bind to a particular chromosome. Each probe is labeled with a different fluorescent dye. These fluorescent probes are applied to the cell biopsy sample and are expected to attach to the specific chromosomes. They can be visualized under a fluorescent microscope. The number of chromosomes of each type (color) present in that cell is counted. The geneticist can thus distinguish normal cells from abnormal cells, such as those with aneuploidy (see Images 4-5). A summary of PGD applications categorized by PCR or FISH is as follows:
Embryo transferAfter the genetic laboratory provides detailed information, the future parents, along with their physicians, decide which embryos should be transferred or frozen and which should not be used. Usually, 2-4 embryos are transferred, depending on the couple's specific conditions. The procedure takes just a few minutes and does not require anesthesia or analgesia. The physician inserts a speculum into the vagina and cleans the cervix, removing all cervical mucus. In some situations, washing with an appropriate fluid is required to facilitate the cleaning of the endocervical canal. A thin plastic catheter, into which the embryologist has transferred the embryos, is then advanced near the top of the uterus. Recently, ultrasound has been used to achieve more precise placement of the embryos. Once the placement of the catheter is correct, preferably 1-2 cm from the top of the uterine cavity, the embryos are expelled from the catheter and deposited into the uterus. After transfer of the embryos, patients usually rest in mild Trendelenburg position on the transfer table for 1-3 hours. The patient is advised to rest during the first 24 hours after the embryo transfer and to engage in only limited activity during the second 24 hours. She may then return to her normal activity level. Note that physical activity or diet has only limited impact on embryo implantation or conception. Once the embryos are transferred, a patient can do little to influence the outcome of her cycle. The patient needs to be followed carefully to ensure that hormonal levels, which are essential in sustaining the pregnancy, are appropriate. The concentration of the hormones in blood is tested on frequent occasions, and when necessary, hormonal levels are maintained or improved by exogenous hormones, most likely progesterone. Because of the complicated metabolism of progesterone, a vaginal or intramuscular application is preferred. When necessary, the production of essential hormones by the ovaries might be improved by the administration of human chorionic gonadotropin in the luteal phase of the cycle. Many pregnancies can be "rescued" by carefully monitoring the patient after embryo transfer. CONSIDERATIONS AND CONTROVERSIESConsiderations and challenges
Controversies
ADVANTAGESCurrently available technology can help eliminate some genetic diseases in the future (eg, Tay-Sachs disease, cystic fibrosis, Huntington disease, X-linked dystrophies). Complete cures for many genetic diseases are not likely to be found soon; therefore, preventing the disease is preferable to waiting for a possible cure to eventually become available. Furthermore, available treatments often have multiple adverse effects. Prolonging the lifespan of affected patients could cause them to develop diseases not previously known to be associated with the particular genetic condition (eg, diabetes, osteoporosis). For instance, as improved treatment prolongs life for individuals with cystic fibrosis, other manifestations of the pancreatic insufficiency and nutritional malabsorption associated with the disease, such as diabetes and osteoporosis, begin to emerge. Most testing for genetic diseases is currently performed through amniocentesis or chorionic villus testing when the fetus is aged 10-16 weeks. If the examination findings reveal a genetically defective fetus, the options available to parents are to have a child with a genetic disease or to have an abortion. This is a difficult and often traumatic decision, especially in advanced pregnancy. However, PGD is performed before pregnancy begins, thus eliminating this dilemma. Persons with a genetic disease or those who know that they are carriers frequently choose to not have children in order to avoid the risk of passing on the disease. PGD allows them the opportunity to have a child free of their particular disease. When PGD becomes more widespread and is accepted and recommended by support societies, the number of babies born with diagnosable genetic diseases should fall dramatically. This will represent a significant reduction of physical and emotional stress related to care for an affected family member and a significant reduction of medical expenses to society. For example, the cost of lifetime medical care of a person with cystic fibrosis is more than $2 million. The expansion of genetic investigation will also open new avenues of understanding of various previously unknown conditions and associations. In 2001, the US National Institutes of Health and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommended testing of patients of childbearing age for cystic fibrosis (American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 2001). Voluminous information will become available from these examinations. Hopefully, other genetic diseases will also become intensively studied in the near future. FUTUREThe first successful cases of PGD in humans were performed in 1988. However, the development and acceptance of PGD since then has been slow, mainly due to the time necessary to develop and learn single-cell diagnostic techniques and to the costs involved. PGD is a relatively new procedure, and much ongoing research is being performed to expand and improve it. However, much more work also must be completed before PGD becomes a more comprehensive, accepted, and widely available procedure. Almost weekly reports on identification of genetic changes tied to various diseases are published in scientific and lay literature. In the future, genetic links to common diseases (eg, diabetes, hypertension, cardiovascular diseases, endometriosis, cancers) may be identified, and PGD will become available to control the transmission of these diseases to future generations. This will gradually lead to the complete eradication of many dreadful genetic diseases. Two new procedures reportedly examine all the chromosomes from a single cell at one time: comparative genomic hybridization and interphase conversion. Comparative genomic hybridization In comparative genomic hybridization, the embryo nucleus is labeled with a fluorescent dye and a control cell is labeled using another color, ie, red or green. The 2 are then cohybridized onto a control metaphase spread, and the ratio between the 2 colors is compared. If the chromosomal analysis shows an excess of red, the embryo nucleus contains an extra chromosome. If an excess of green is apparent, then the embryo nucleus is missing one of these chromosomes. Currently, this technique takes 72 hours, and embryo cryopreservation is necessary to provide the time necessary to undertake the diagnosis. A successful case has been reported in Australia. Interphase conversion In interphase conversion, an interphase nucleus is converted to metaphase by fusing the interphase nucleus with an enucleated oocyte (eg, bovine). When the interphase nucleus is induced into metaphase, all the chromosomes in the nucleus can be examined. For PCR, fluorescence multiplex PCR has already been applied to PGD cases. DNA chip technology allows more genes to be analyzed. However, the value of this new technology for PGD is limited because the mutation considered to be present is known before PGD is performed and only a few polymorphic markers are required. However, increasing the number of diseases that can be diagnosed by single-cell PCR is crucial so that more patients can benefit from PGD. MULTIMEDIA
REFERENCES
Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis excerpt Article Last Updated: Apr 13, 2005 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||