Continually Updated Clinical Reference
 
 
  All Sources     eMedicine     Medscape     Drug Reference     MEDLINE
 
You are in: eMedicine Specialties > Medicine, Ob/Gyn, Psychiatry, and Surgery > Obstetrics/gynecology

Assisted Reproduction Technology

Last Updated: July 20, 2006
Email to a Colleague
Synonyms and related keywords: assisted reproduction technology, fecundability, monthly probability of conceiving, assisted reproductive technology, ART, intracytoplasmic sperm injection, ICSI, assisted hatching, AH, infertility, in vitro fertilization, IVF, human reproduction, conception difficulty, artificial insemination, AI, reproductive endocrinology, fertility therapy, basal body temperature, BBT, clomiphene citrate challenge test, CCCT, decreased ovarian reserve, unexplained infertility, fallopian tube damage, tubal damage, intrauterine insemination, IUI, fertility therapy, gamete intrafallopian transfer, GIFT, zygote intrafallopian transfer, ZIFT, tubal embryo transfer, TET

  AUTHOR INFORMATION Section 1 of 8    Click here to go to the next section in this topic
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

Author: John C Petrozza, MD, Instructor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Harvard Medical School; Chief, Division of Reproductive Medicine and IVF, Vincent Obstetrics and Gynecology, Massachusetts General Hospital

Coauthor(s): Aaron Kyle Styer, MD, Instructor, Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology, and Reproductive Biology, Harvard Medical School; Clinical Fellow, MGH Fertility Center, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Massachusetts General Hospital

John C Petrozza, MD, is a member of the following medical societies: American Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, American Society for Reproductive Medicine, Massachusetts Medical Society, and Society for Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility

Editor(s): Bryan D Cowan, MD, Director, Division of Reproductive Endocrinology, Professor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Mississippi College of Medicine; Francisco Talavera, PharmD, PhD, Senior Pharmacy Editor, eMedicine; Carl Vernon Smith, MD, Professor, Chairman, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Nebraska College of Medicine; Frederick B Gaupp, MD, Consulting Staff, Department of Family Practice, Assumption Community Hospital; and Lee P Shulman, MD, Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University; Chief, Division of Reproductive Genetics, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Prentice Women's Hospital, Northwestern Memorial Hospital

Disclosure


  INTRODUCTION Section 2 of 8   Click here to go to the previous section in this topic Click here to go to the top of this page Click here to go to the next section in this topic
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

Infertility is a very common condition affecting approximately 13-14% of reproductive-aged couples. Despite a stable prevalence of infertility in this population, the demand for infertility services has increased substantially over the past decade. This increase is primarily due to the "Baby Boom generation" (ie, the significantly large US generation conceived immediately after World War II) entering into the reproductive age group at a time of highly publicized technological advances. Although infertility represents a small facet of the broad intellectual scope of reproductive endocrinology, patients seeking infertility treatment represent the mainstay of a clinical reproductive endocrinologist's practice.

Infertility is defined as the inability to conceive after 1 year of properly timed unprotected intercourse. This definition is based on the cumulative probability of pregnancy (see Table 1).

Table 1. Cumulative Probability of Pregnancy in Couples With Normal Fertility (All Reproductive-aged Women)

Month Monthly Probability Cumulative Probability
1 0.2 0.20
2 0.2 0.36
3 0.2 0.49
4 0.2 0.59
5 0.2 0.67
6 0.2 0.74
7 0.2 0.79
8 0.2 0.83
9 0.2 0.86
10 0.2 0.89
11 0.2 0.91
12 0.2 0.93

Assuming a constant monthly probability of conceiving (fecundability) of 20%, the cumulative pregnancy rate after 12 months is 93%. Approximately 50% of couples should become pregnant after 3 months, but only an additional 25% conceive if attempting pregnancy an additional 2 months. During patient counseling, fostering an understanding of the cumulative probability of pregnancy and emphasizing that most fertility therapy (other than in vitro fertilization [IVF]) is designed to improve monthly fecundability to as close to the 20% baseline (normal fertile couples) as possible is important.

Conventional infertility treatment (excluding IVF) is usually continued until the cumulative pregnancy rate is at least 50%. Because fecundability rates are clearly higher in younger women and lower in older women, counseling a 40-year-old woman to wait 1 year before seeking fertility services is not appropriate. In women older than 35 years, a complete evaluation at 4-6 months is best because their potential response to any therapy may be suboptimal due to diminished ovarian reserve.

For excellent patient education resources, visit eMedicine's Pregnancy and Reproduction Center. Also, see eMedicine's patient education articles Infertility, In Vitro Fertilization, and Miscarriage.
  PREVALENCE Section 3 of 8   Click here to go to the previous section in this topic Click here to go to the top of this page Click here to go to the next section in this topic
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

The prevalence of infertility is approximately 13-14%. This rate is based on data from a series of personal interviews with a cohort of 8000 representative infertile women of reproductive age conducted by the National Survey of Family Growth and the National Center for Health Statistics of the US Department of Health and Human Services in 1976, 1982, and 1988. After controlling for sterilization in recruited interviewees, the prevalence of infertility remained unchanged from 1964 (13.3%) to 1988 (13.7%).

Aging and fertility

An inverse relationship exists between female age and fertility. That is, fecundability decreases with advancing age. At least one third of women who defer attempting conception until the middle of their fourth decade have difficulty conceiving, while 50% of women older than 40 years who defer attempting conception have difficulty conceiving.

The relationship between age and fertility has been consistently demonstrated in several studies, including the following:

One drawback of the above studies is the lack of adjustment for decrease in coital frequency with age and duration of marriage.

Table 2. Relative Fertility Rates by Age
Group Relative Fertility Rate
Age, nulliparous women, y  
38-39 1.00
38-40 0.92
38-41 0.79
38-42 0.75
38-43 0.55
38-44 0.48
38-45 0.34
45 0.28
Age, parous women, y  
38-39 1.00
38-40 1.09
38-41 1.00
38-42 0.90
38-43 0.86
38-44 0.77
38-45 0.64
45 0.49

Ovarian life cycle

A constant decline in the number of oocytes begins at 20 weeks' gestation when the female fetus has approximately 6-7 million oogonia (largest lifetime endowment). The number of oocytes decreases to approximately 2-3 million at birth and decreases again to 300,000 at the time of puberty. Ironically, the human female has lost most of her eggs before she is able to reproduce.

After the onset of puberty and menses, the female human ovary recruits at least 30-50 oocytes during each menstrual cycle. The oocytes compete with one another to become the dominant follicle and eventually ovulate to be released as an egg capable of being fertilized. Ten to fifteen years prior to the onset of menopause, rapid follicular loss occurs because more oocytes are being recruited each month in hopes of selecting a healthy dominant follicle. In the years immediately prior to menopause, the menstrual cycle begins to shorten because of subtle elevations in follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) levels and decreases in inhibin-B concentration. This contributes to decreased pregnancy rates, increased miscarriage rates (up to 50% for women in the middle of their fifth decade), and decreased live-born rates.
  DIAGNOSTIC TESTS Section 4 of 8   Click here to go to the previous section in this topic Click here to go to the top of this page Click here to go to the next section in this topic
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

When evaluating the infertile couple, diagnostic studies should be selected that are clearly indicated and will potentially affect the type of infertility treatment the patient may require. The multiple causes of infertility are listed in Table 3.

Table 3. Causes of Infertility
Cause Couples Women
Male 35% --
Ovulatory 15% 40%
Tubal 35% 40%
Unexplained 10% 10%
Other 5% 10%

While evaluating the infertile couple, obtaining a thorough history is critical. During an office visit, the scope of questions asked during the evaluation includes the following:

Ideally, the male partner should be present during the initial interview because it not only allows the physician to reinforce that infertility is a couple's issue but also acquaints the male to the physician's management style and provides an opportunity for clarification of any tests that may be ordered. Most importantly, having both members of the couple at the initial visit allows the physician to observe the interaction between the couple to assess whether any potential conflicts or stresses exist that need to be addressed before proceeding further with evaluation and/or treatment.

Initial tests should be selected based upon the findings from the history and physical examination. If the history is unclear, then tests that address the above-mentioned major categories of infertility should be obtained.

Ovulatory function testing

Basal body temperature monitoring

Basal body temperature (BBT) monitoring is more of a historical method for determining the correct timing of intercourse. A significant rise in temperature is not noted until 2 days after the luteinizing hormone (LH) peak, which occurs after the day of ovulation. Since most studies show that the best day to introduce sperm into the female reproductive tract is either the day of ovulation or the day before ovulation, BBT monitoring is not useful for coital timing in a current cycle but best serves as a retrospective method to confirm the time of ovulation. Urine LH kits are a more useful method to prospectively predict the day of ovulation.

Clomiphene citrate challenge test

Clomiphene citrate (100 mg PO qd) is administered on cycle days 5-9. FSH and estradiol levels are drawn on days 3 and 10. If the day-3 or day-10 FSH level is greater than 15 mIU/mL or the day-3 estradiol level is greater than 75 pg/mL, the test results are considered abnormal. The rationale is that if the woman has an elevated day-10 estradiol level due to the clomiphene, yet her FSH level is not suppressed (estrogen suppresses FSH by a negative feedback mechanism), she has significant decreased ovarian reserve.

An abnormal test result indicates that the woman has a 1-3% chance of taking home a healthy baby. Traditionally, FSH and estradiol levels are obtained on cycle days 2-4. Typically, if the FSH level is greater than 15 mIU/mL or the estradiol level is greater than 75 pg/mL, the prognosis is poor. In these patients, a low inhibin-B concentration (<35) helps support the diagnosis.

Male factor testing

Semen analysis:

For optimum and consistent results, abstinence is required at least 3-5 days prior to semen collection. The World Health Organization recommends the following for normal values:

  • Volume - At least 2 mL or greater

  • Sperm concentration - Twenty million/mL

  • Motility - At least 50% or more with forward progression

  • Morphology - At least 30% or more normal forms (14% strict Kruger criteria)

  • White blood cells - Fewer than 1 million/mL

  • Round cells - Fewer than 5 million/mL

Many centers conduct a second phase to the semen analysis to determine the strength of the sperm. After 60 minutes, the semen is analyzed again, with the expectation that at least 25% of the sperm will remain motile with forward progression. A swim-up technique that separates the motile sperm from the nonmotile sperm is also used. A total of at least 1 million motile sperm is considered adequate following swim up

Tubal disease testing

In patients with unremarkable history or examination findings, a hysterosalpingogram (HSG) performed 2-5 days after the cessation of menstrual flow is the procedure of choice. The overall risk of infection is 1%, and most patients do not require antibiotic prophylaxis. Pretreatment with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) is recommended with the rare patient requiring a mild sedative.

HSG requires approximately 10 minutes to complete, and the results are conveyed immediately to the patient. This procedure is not only diagnostic, but it can be therapeutic (for approximately 6 mo), primarily when using an oil-based dye.

If the patient has still failed to conceive, a diagnostic laparoscopy is usually indicated. In patients undergoing laparoscopy, approximately 50% will have some type of pelvic pathology, usually adhesions or endometriosis.

A history of pelvic inflammatory disease, septic abortion, ruptured appendix, tubal surgery, or ectopic pregnancy should alert the physician to the possibility of tubal damage. In these patients or in patients with significant pelvic pain during the physical examination, proceeding to a diagnostic laparoscopy rather than an HSG may be more prudent given the high probability of pelvic pathology.

Cervical disease testing

Women who have had cervical cone biopsies or trauma to the cervix are at risk for cervical abnormalities. If a cervical abnormality is found, the most logical approach is to recommend bypassing the cervix with intrauterine inseminations, especially if the rest of the findings from the infertility evaluation are normal. In this situation, use of an intrauterine insemination (IUI) catheter raises the fecundability rate for the couple to 20%.

Those patients who choose to continue with timed coitus, a postcoital test may be useful. Testing should be periovulatory in nature and based on findings from a urine LH predictor kit.

With a postcoital test (PCT), the couple should have intercourse in the morning and the woman should have her test performed by the late morning or early afternoon. At least 2 hours and no more than 24 hours should elapse between coitus and the postcoital test. If the patient is undergoing a treatment protocol that involves clomiphene citrate, performing the postcoital test after the first coitus is best because of the medicine's possible negative effect on the cervical mucus. If the test result is abnormal, an IUI should be performed. PCT reference ranges include the following:

  • Mucus stretchability (spinnbarkeit) - From 8-10 cm

  • Clarity - Clear

  • Semen pH - Greater than 7.0

  • Sperm - More than 1 forward-moving sperm per high-power field (HPF) (More than 20 motile sperm/HPF is almost always associated with a sperm concentration within the reference range on results from a semen analysis.)

A lack of consensus exists regarding the accuracy, precision, and utility of the PCT in the modern infertility evaluation.

Testing for uterine disease

Similar to tubal disease, obtaining a history from the patient is the most important diagnostic tool. A history of repetitive elective abortions, uterine surgery, postpartum uterine infections, retained products of conception, or postpartum curettage should alert the clinician to a possible uterine factor. A history of abnormal bleeding, such as midcycle spotting, may represent an intrauterine polyp or fibroid. Recurrent malpresentation during pregnancy or recurrent pregnancy loss often suggests a uterine anomaly, such as a septum or bicornuate uterus.

A screening transvaginal ultrasonography performed immediately following the cessation of menses may demonstrate a uterine leiomyoma (fibroid), adenomyosis, or an endometrial polyp.

HSG is performed after the initial history to evaluate the fallopian tubes and the uterine cavity. If a defect is found in the uterine cavity, performing a hysteroscopy helps further delineate and possibly treat the abnormality.

If the patient has known blocked tubes and is scheduled for IVF, a sonohysterogram (SHG) is more appropriate and less uncomfortable for the patient. An SHG is performed by placing a small catheter in the uterine cavity and instilling sterile saline to separate the endometrial walls under ultrasonographic guidance. Interestingly, the SHG is more sensitive than an HSG in delineating fibroids and polyps.

An office-based hysteroscopy is another option that many physicians prefer to use to directly visualize the uterine cavity or remove very small polyps or adhesions without the need for significant sedation.

Testing for endocrine abnormalities

Any evidence of the following should warrant selective hormonal studies.

  • Hirsutism

  • Abnormal weight gain

  • Oily skin or acne

  • Purple striae on the abdomen

  • Polyuria/polydipsia

  • Irregular menses

If the patient displays hirsutism, with or without menstrual irregularity, androgen studies such as dehydroepiandrosterone sulfate (DHEA-S), total testosterone, and 17-hydroxyprogesterone should be performed. If unusual weight gain or fatigue develops, a thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) should be obtained. If galactorrhea or irregular menses occurs, measuring the prolactin level should be considered. Acanthosis nigricans suggests hyperinsulinemia and requires confirmation by obtaining fasting insulin and glucose levels.

Luteal phase assessment

A deficiency in progesterone production by the corpus luteum (CL) has historically been attributed to the cause of infertility and recurrent pregnancy loss in many women with otherwise unexplained miscarriages.

The significance and presence of an inadequate luteal phase (also referred to as luteal phase defect has been questioned throughout the literature. Traditionally, diagnosis of a luteal phase defect has been determined histologically (a lag of >2 d histologically compared with the day of the cycle, based on the actual day of ovulation). Some physicians prefer to use low luteal phase progesterone levels (<10 ng/mL) 6 days after ovulation as their method of diagnosis, with good correlation to histologic findings if repeated in 3 separate menstrual cycles.

Isolated luteal phase defects (by histological criteria) are observed in 30-40% of healthy fertile couples as well as infertile couples, implying that this defect must be a repetitive event to be a true cause of infertility or miscarriage.

No evidence suggests that the addition of exogenous progesterone is of any benefit to pregnancy outcomes, suggesting a potential defect in endometrial receptivity during the implantation stage.

Unexplained infertility

By definition, a physician makes the diagnosis of unexplained infertility after all tests are completed, including a diagnostic laparoscopy with or without a hysteroscopy. In modern practice, unexplained infertility is considered after all test results are negative, prior to any surgery, and in a patient with an unremarkable history and physical examination findings.

Many couples are subfertile, meaning that their fecundability rate is approximately 3-5%, with many conceiving within a 3-year period without medication. In this situation, the physician is involved more to expedite a pregnancy rather than to treat an actual infertility etiology.

Quick Find
Author Information
Introduction
Prevalence
Diagnostic Tests
Treatment
The Role Of The Physician
Pictures
Bibliography

Click for related images.

Patient Education



  TREATMENT Section 5 of 8   Click here to go to the previous section in this topic Click here to go to the top of this page Click here to go to the next section in this topic
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

Treatment of ovulatory dysfunction

If a patient has a normal ovarian reserve, determining the potential cause of the ovulatory defect is prudent. The practitioner should consider the following scenarios prior to initiating treatment. In the presence of obesity and chronic anovulation, polycystic ovarian (PCO) syndrome or Cushing disease may be evident and in the case of hirsutism, the patient may have elevated androgen levels or hyperinsulinemia, requiring further testing. If the physical examination findings are unremarkable, ovulation induction is the next treatment approach to consider.

The following clomiphene citrate (CC) treatment regimens are often used for ovulation induction in patients with idiopathic ovulatory dysfunction or PCO syndrome:

  • Clomiphene citrate (50 mg on days 5-9)

  • Clomiphene citrate (100 mg on days 2-6) plus FSH (1-2 amps starting on day 8)

  • Clomiphene citrate plus human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) for ovulation induction

  • Elevated androgen levels – Dexamethasone (0.25 mg/d) plus clomiphene citrate

  • Hyperinsulinemia with elevated androgens - Metformin (500 mg tid) plus clomiphene citrate (Many women spontaneously ovulate on metformin alone; thus, many clinicians allow a trial of 1-3 mo prior to adding clomiphene citrate.)

  • Aromatase inhibitors (Letrozole) (2.5 mg PO on cycle days 3-7) has been shown in early studies to work as well as clomiphene citrate to induce mono-ovulation and to have little or no adverse affect on endometrial thickness.

The goal of therapy is to achieve 3 ovulatory cycles; 40-50% of women should become pregnant in this timeframe in the absence of any other abnormalities. If conception has not occurred after 3 clomiphene citrate cycles, the practitioner should investigate other causes of infertility. No more than 6 consecutive cycles are recommended because of the theoretical risk of borderline ovarian tumors and extremely low pregnancy success rates after this point.

Evidence suggests that starting clomiphene citrate earlier (day 2 or 3) is more beneficial because this conforms to a more typical cycle length of 28 days. Beginning a clomiphene citrate cycle on day 2 or 3 promotes ovulation around days 12-16, which is more physiologic and may avoid delayed ovulation and excessive maturity of the oocyte. Studies from the 1970s in women with documented delayed ovulation (after cycle day 16) revealed a higher relative miscarriage rate. This was believed to be caused by meiotic dysfunction within the oocyte.

Ovulation (LH) predictor kits are much easier for patients to use when clomiphene citrate is started on day 2 or 3. LH levels are normally elevated after the patient takes clomiphene citrate, and the half-life of the medication is 5 days. Thus, in a cycle day 5-9 regimen, a patient may receive a false-positive reading if she follows the directions on the kit and starts monitoring on cycle days 12-13.

Evidence demonstrates that a day 2 or 3 clomiphene citrate start allows the endometrium to thicken to a more normal, physiologic range. Endometrial thinning is a well-known adverse effect of clomiphene citrate. An endometrium that is thinner than 7-8 mm has been associated with a lower pregnancy rate in IVF cycles.

Treatment of male factor

Confirm any abnormal study result with a repeat semen analysis. If the results remain abnormal, refer the patient to a urologist to eliminate any genetic, anatomic, hormonal, or infectious causes. If the volume is less than 1 mL, consider retrograde ejaculation and obtain an analysis of the urine.

If the sperm concentration is less than 20 million/mL, yet the swim-up extraction yields at least 1 million total motile sperm, IUI is the treatment of choice. Simple sperm washing can be performed in the office if a centrifuge is available. Allow the semen to liquify on a warming plate at 37°C; then, suspend the semen in approximately 15-20 mL of washing medium (eg, Earl) and centrifuge it for 60 seconds. Resuspend the pellet in another 15-20 mL of medium and centrifuge again. The supernatant is removed, and 0.5 mL of the medium is used to resuspend the sperm pellet. Using an intrauterine catheter, deposit the sperm into the uterus on the day of ovulation

Treatment of tubal disease

IVF offers the best chance for conception in patients with significant tubal disease. Often, if only 1 tube is affected, ovarian stimulation with gonadotropins produces mature oocytes in the ovary near the patent tube. In patients with minimal or moderate tubal disease, laparoscopic lysis of adhesions and procedures should be performed to normalize tubal function, with an emphasis on prevention of adhesion recurrence. In patients with an irreparable hydrosalpinx, removing the tube or disconnecting it from the uterus may reduce the risk of a tubal pregnancy and enhance embryo implantation if the patient requires IVF.

Pregnancy rate following treatment can be dependent upon location of tubal disease (see Table 4).

Laparoscopic lysis of adhesions offers the patient a window of opportunity to conceive either naturally or with minimal types of therapy. If only proximal tubal occlusion is present, these obstructions can be fixed with a balloon tuboplasty under fluoroscopic guidance similar to the common angioplastic procedure in cardiology.

Table 4. Treatment of Tubal Pathology
Procedure Pregnancy Rate
(3-6 mo)
Lysis of adhesions 50%
Mild distal obstructive disease 80%
Moderate distal obstructive disease 30%
Severe distal obstructive disease 15%
Proximal tubal obstruction: 30%

Treatment of cervical factor

In most patients, IUIs offer the most reasonable option for treatment. Some patients remain adamant that they want to continue with timed coitus despite a cervical issue. In women with thick mucus (poor spinnbarkeit), the addition of conjugated estrogen (Premarin at 0.625 mg or Estrace at 2 mg) 8-9 days prior to ovulation has its supporters but lacks clear clinical value. In some studies, if the pH is less than 7.0, a precoital douche of 1 tablespoon of sodium bicarbonate in 1 quart of water has shown good results. The presence of antisperm antibodies in the female or male warrants IUIs. If the antibodies are on the sperm itself, washing the sperm with a chymotrypsin/galactose preparation may improve sperm motility.

Treatment of uterine factor

An operative hysteroscopy is usually required to lyse adhesions or remove endometrial polyps or submucosal fibroids. Intramural fibroids often must be removed by laparotomy and myomectomy, paying close attention to microsurgical technique and adhesion prevention. Many times, subserosal fibroids may impinge on a fallopian tube. In severe cases of intrauterine adhesions that encompass most of the uterine cavity, the best option for conception may be through the use of a gestational carrier.

Treatment of endocrine abnormalities

Ensure that any endocrine abnormality is normalized prior to attempts at conception. Keep in mind that women with luteal phase defects also have ovulatory dysfunction. Clomiphene citrate, as previously mentioned, and luteal phase progesterone supplementation may be potentially effective treatments. The recommended progesterone is either micronized progesterone in vaginal suppositories (50-100 mg bid) or progesterone vaginal cream (Crinone 8%; 90 mg/d). Oral micronized progesterone may be used but causes significant somnolence and adverse central nervous system effects (eg, depression).

Treatment of unexplained infertility

The choice of treatment protocol depends on how aggressive the couple wants to be with their efforts to conceive. Most physicians start with either clomiphene citrate or gonadotropins in conjunction with IUIs. Involve the couple in the decision-making process, and ensure that they completely understand the success rates (see Table 5) and the risks of multiple pregnancy with each treatment protocol.

Table 5. Unexplained Infertility and Pregnancy Rates per Cycle According to Treatment
Protocol Pregnancy Rate, %
No treatment 1.3-4.1
IUI alone 3.8
Clomiphene with timed coitus 5.6
Clomiphene with IUI 10
Gonadotropins with timed coitus 7.7
Gonadotropins with IUI 17.1
IVF 35-50

In vitro fertilization (IVF)

The first IVF pregnancy was achieved in 1978. Since then, the number of IVF centers and IVF procedures performed has increased dramatically. An intense effort to obtain insurance coverage for these services has also occurred. With the support of organizations such as RESOLVE (ie, the National Fertility Association), 13 US states have the opportunity to provide coverage for these services. Currently, 2 states (Massachusetts and Rhode Island) offer full coverage. Other states exempt health maintenance organization programs, private insurers, or companies with few employees. Other states offer lifetime limits to their coverage (eg, Ohio, $2000; Arkansas, $15,000). Still other states require insurers to offer coverage but do not require employers to purchase plans that actually provide that coverage. The actual cost per paid subscriber is not substantial. A recent study in Massachusetts, which has approximately 5000 IVF cycles per year, calculated that the increase is only$25 per year per subscriber.

As a result of the Fertility Clinic Success Rate and Certification Act, the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) gathers information from 391 of the 428 fertility clinics throughout the United States. Information from 2002 shows that 115,392 ART cycles were performed. See Image 1 for details on the different types of procedures performed.

Assisted reproductive techniques

Gamete intrafallopian transfer (GIFT) was developed in 1984 for women with unexplained infertility. At that time, GIFT provided much better pregnancy rates, had a much greater degree of naturalness, and was more acceptable in certain religious and ethnic communities (in which fertilization inside the woman's body is the only type allowed). During this procedure, the patient undergoes a controlled ovarian hyperstimulation. The oocytes are retrieved transvaginally under ultrasonographic guidance, and 3-4 oocytes are placed via laparoscopy into one of the fallopian tubes along with sperm.

Zygote intrafallopian transfer (ZIFT) is used for couples with a significant male factor. The oocytes are retrieved similar to GIFT, but they are allowed to fertilize in vitro in the laboratory. At the 2-pronuclear stage (usually 24 h later), 3-4 embryos are transferred via laparoscopy into one of the fallopian tubes. If the embryos are allowed to develop to greater than a 2-cell stage, the procedure is termed tubal embryo transfer (TET). The only benefit to a ZIFT or TET versus the more traditional IVF is for women who are thought to have compromised embryo quality due to embryo in vitro culture. Placing these zygotes or embryos back into their own natural incubators is thought to enhance subsequent development, with improved pregnancy rates.

With the development of enhanced culture media, the success rates for IVF are now comparable, if not better, to those of GIFT and ZIFT.

Interpreting IVF success rates

Comparing one program's success rate to another is difficult because of all the variables involved. For instance, perhaps a program is very selective with its patients, allowing only those with a chance for success based on diagnosis, age, or ovarian reserve. Programs in states that are mandated to cover fertility therapy may be more likely to treat patients with a low chance for success simply because the patient has insurance or, perhaps, because the programs may perform more IVF cycles than programs in states without such a mandate. Some have suggested that programs in mandated states, due to the treatment algorithms enforced by the insurance companies, often have to treat patients without a male or tubal factor for many months with insemination cycles before getting approval for IVF coverage. Thus, these patients may actually be the most difficult patients to treat when they eventually get to IVF.

On the other hand, programs in states without a mandate may be dealing with more difficult patients who have had multiple surgeries and other covered or less costly therapy before ultimately deciding on IVF. However, some argue that many of these programs often take patients directly to IVF, or after a few insemination cycles, and, thus, these patients are more likely to be successful.

In general, like any statistical analysis, the more IVF cycles a program has performed, the more valid the numbers. The cancellation rate is a critical number. If the rate is high, the program is possibly very selective for those patients it allows to proceed to egg retrieval. This type of program would rather cancel the patient's procedure than have a low chance for success that may ultimately hurt its overall success rates. The pregnancy rate per retrieval is higher compared with the pregnancy rate per transfer. If this difference is large, it may reflect the quality of the laboratory. The implantation rate refers to thepregnancy rate divided by the number of embryos transferred. If the implantation rate is low and the pregnancy rate is high, this suggests that the program is transferring a large number of embryos per patient to achieve that success. Chances are good that the program's multiple pregnancy rate is high. Optimally, the better programs have a low cancellation rate and good pregnancy and implantation rates.

The ultimate critical number is the birth rate because this represents the final goal of the patient and the physician. This goal is also less vulnerable to misinterpretation than the pregnancy rate (single positive hCG vs serial increases) or the clinical pregnancy rate (gestational sac vs fetal pole vs fetal pole with heartbeat).

IVF outcomes

In 2002, 115,392 IVF cycles were reported started with a 14.6% cancellation rate, and, 45,751 pregnancies were confirmed delivered. One of every 2.5 IVF cycles started ended in a live birth. See Image 3 for the detailed success rates. When observing cycles that ended in a uterine pregnancy (30.5%), most ended in a singleton birth. The miscarriage rate is no higher than that with a spontaneous pregnancy (ie, 16.1%). These rates are detailed in Image 4.

Guidelines for embryo transfer

In response to the significant numbers of higher order multiple pregnancies generated from ART, the American Society of Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) released guidelines for the number of embryos transferred in 1999. Image 5 shows the risk of having a multiple-fetus pregnancy using fresh, nondonor embryos.

In 2002, the total multiple-fetus pregnancy rate was 36%. A lower number of deliveries of triplets or more compared to pregnancies suggests that these pregnancies were either iatrogenically reduced, spontaneously reduced, or resulted in a miscarriage.

Increasing the number of embryos transferred from 1 to 2 not only increases the chance for a live birth but also increases the likelihood of a multiple-infant pregnancy. However, transferring more than 2 embryos may not increase the overall live birth rate.

Many variables affect the decision of how many embryos to transfer. Factors such as the patient's age, embryo quality, number of prior failed IVF cycles, and use of frozen-thawed embryos are important to consider. New data from Europe suggests that a single embryo transfer in the appropriate patient results in approximately a 35% pregnancy rate with a less than 1% multiple pregnancy rate. These patients typically have embryos that are frozen, ensuring that their cumulative pregnancy rate using either fresh or frozen embryos is similar to transferring 2 or more embryos. Images 6 and 7 show the relationship between the number of embryos transferred and the risk of having a multiple-infant birth in women of all ages and in women younger than 35 years. Single embryo transfer is appropriate in certain situations where the likelihood of a multiple pregnancy is high. This may include women younger than 35 years, women who conceived with first IVF cycle, women with only tubal factorinfertility, women with concerns about multiple gestation, and donor egg recipients.

Factors contributing to IVF success

The most important factor that determines a successful cycle is the female patient's age. As mentioned previously, decreases in fecundity rates are observed beginning as early as age 30 years. The dramatic effect that age has on fecundability is also observed in ART (see Image 7). Most egg donors are aged 20-35 years, allowing for an optimal control group to observe these differences.

Ultimately, the success of ARTs mimics the overall fecundity trend observed in the general fertile population. That is, pregnancy and live birth rates start to decrease beginning around age 30 years and continue to decrease until the chance of having a live birth is so low that the benefit of ARTs must be evaluated. In women older than 40 years, the chance of having a liveborn infant with a chromosomal abnormality also increases. Image 7 shows the live birth rate with ARTs based on the patient's age and whether she uses her own oocytes or donor eggs, which are typically harvested from women aged 20-35 years.

Oocyte retrieval

Oocyte retrieval is performed approximately 36 hours after 10,000 U of hCG is administered to allow for the resumption of meiosis, cytoplasmic maturation, and loosening of the oocytes within the follicle. This allows for a lower optimal vacuum pressure during aspiration and ultimately less oocyte damage.

The 3 basic methods to retrieve oocytes are laparoscopic, transabdominal, or transvaginal. The laparoscopic approach was used frequently in the 1980s, especially when a GIFT procedure was planned. Often, only the follicles that could be seen on the surface of the ovary were removed, and, if the ovary was very mobile, traction was required to support the ovary as the follicles were aspirated. Associated morbidity occurred with the procedure, which included infection and injury to the pelvic organs. General endotracheal anesthesia was usually used, and the patient's recovery often lasted 2-3 days. As the quality of ultrasonographic images and culture media improved, the need for laparoscopy decreased.

In 1981, ultrasonographic-guided aspiration was first described. Initially, the transabdominal approach was used, usually with the aspirating needle going through the bladder, which, when full, provided a window of visualization for the person operating the abdominal ultrasonographic probe.

Although still used for retrieval of oocytes from ovaries that are adhered high up in the pelvis or to the fundus of the uterus, the transabdominal approach was superseded by the transvaginal approach. The first transvaginal retrieval was performed in 1984 and has now become the procedure of choice because of its ease and low morbidity.

Micromanipulation

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) is the treatment of choice for couples in whom the male partner has azoospermia or severe oligospermia. ICSI is also indicated for men with significant antisperm antibodies, low sperm motility, or significantly abnormal sperm morphology (Kruger strict morphology <4%).

ICSI is used when poor fertilization occurs with regular insemination techniques in the laboratory. ICSI may be used when a limited amount of sperm is available, such as in couples where the man has stored sperm prior to chemotherapy. ICSI is indicated in certain preimplantation genetic (PGD) procedures—specifically those cases being evaluated for single-gene recessive disorders. This prevents the potential contamination of the specimen with sperm that may be attached to the egg.

Sperm can be obtained from the ejaculate or directly from the epididymis. Recently, success was obtained with spermatids from testicular biopsies. See Image 8 for success rates with ICSI.

The potential transmission of a genetic abnormality is a possibility when ICSI is performed. The normal barrier for morphologically abnormal sperm that tend to have genetic abnormalities (ie, zonal pellucida) is bypassed with ICSI. Morphologically normal sperm may also have genetic abnormalities. Approximately 10% of sperm from healthy men have chromosomal abnormalities. Men who are infertile have a 5-7% chance of having a chromosomal abnormality. Chromosomal abnormalities include microdeletions of the long arm of the Y chromosome in areas AZFa, AZFb, and AZFc (DAZ or deleted in azoospermia region). These deletions can be passed on to male offspring, with resulting oligospermia.

Some data suggest a 30% increase in birth defects in children conceived with ICSI. Overall, this implies that the risk of having a child with a birth defect from ART with ICSI goes from a normal baseline of 3% to, at most, 4%.

Approximately 1-2% of men with azoospermia have genetic translocation, Klinefelter syndrome (47XXY), or a congenital bilateral absence of the vas deferens, which is associated with mutations in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator (CFTR) gene or the 5T allele.

In the situation where the male partner has the CFTR mutation, the female partner should also be screened for cystic fibrosis. In any couple undergoing ICSI for male factor infertility, a karyotype and Y-DNA mapping should be considered if the sperm concentration is less than 5 million/mL, and genetic counseling should be offered. Prenatal testing of ICSI pregnancies has revealed an incidence of 0.83% of sex chromosome abnormalities (higher than those reported for spontaneous pregnancies).
  THE ROLE OF THE PHYSICIAN Section 6 of 8   Click here to go to the previous section in this topic Click here to go to the top of this page Click here to go to the next section in this topic
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

Most patients with infertility are anxious, knowledgeable, familiar with the Internet, and know other people who went through the fertility process. Therefore, the physician should strive to be calm, informative, a good listener, and willing to allow the patient to be involved. The routine ordering of unindicated tests is not advised. Realizing that a substantial number of pregnancies occur in infertile couples without therapy is important, irrespective of the diagnosis. Many couples move from fertility center to fertility center, and some conceive, despite no changes in therapy. The physician should be willing to seek a second opinion if all treatments have failed, especially before considering donor sperm, donor oocytes, a gestational carrier, or adoption. Finally, the physician must help to dispel many myths that patients and other doctors have regarding fertility. These may include the following:

  PICTURES Section 7 of 8   Click here to go to the previous section in this topic Click here to go to the top of this page Click here to go to the next section in this topic
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

Caption: Picture 1. Assisted reproduction technique procedures. Rates from the United States in 2003. Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
Caption: Picture 2. Live births per retrieval for different types of assisted reproduction technique procedures (2003). Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
Caption: Picture 3. 2003 success rates for assisted reproduction technique cycles using fresh nondonor eggs. Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
Caption: Picture 4. Outcomes of pregnancies from assisted reproduction technique cycles using fresh nondonor eggs or embryos (2003). Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
Caption: Picture 5. 2003 multifetal pregnancy rates from assisted reproduction technique cycles using fresh nondonor oocytes or embryos. Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
Caption: Picture 6. 2003 live birth and multiple-infant birth rates using fresh nondonor oocytes or embryos by number of embryos transferred. Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
Caption: Picture 7. Live birth rates per transfer for fresh embryos by age (top image) and from patient or donor eggs (bottom image) (1996, 2002, 2003). Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
Caption: Picture 8. 2003 success rates using intracytoplasmic sperm injection in couples with male-factor infertility. Adapted from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Click to see larger pictureClick to see detailView Full Size Image
Picture Type: Graph
  BIBLIOGRAPHY Section 8 of 8   Click here to go to the previous section in this topic Click here to go to the top of this page
Author Information Introduction Prevalence Diagnostic Tests Treatment The Role Of The Physician Pictures Bibliography

  • Abma JC, Chandra A, Mosher WD, et al: Fertility, family planning, and women's health: new data from the 1995 National Survey of Family Growth. Vital Health Stat 23 1997 May; (19): 1-114[Medline].
  • Barbieri RL: Infertility. In: Yen SSC, Jaffe RB, Barbieri RL, eds. Reproductive Endocrinology - Physiology, Pathophysiology, and Clinical Management. 4th ed. Philadelphia, Pa: WB Saunders; 1999: 588.
  • Biljan MM, Mahutte NG, Tulandi T, Tan SL: Prospective randomized double-blind trial of the correlation between time of administration and antiestrogenic effects of clomiphene citrate on reproductive end organs. Fertil Steril 1999 Apr; 71(4): 633-8[Medline].
  • Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: 2002 Assisted Reproductive Technology Success Rates. In: National Summary and Fertility Clinic Reports. Atlanta, Ga: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2002.
  • Confino E, Tur-Kaspa I, DeCherney A, et al: Transcervical balloon tuboplasty. A multicenter study. JAMA 1990 Oct 24-31; 264(16): 2079-82[Medline].
  • Crosignani PG, Collins J, Cooke ID, et al: Recommendations of the ESHRE workshop on 'Unexplained Infertility'. Anacapri, August 28-9, 1992. Hum Reprod 1993 Jun; 8(6): 977-80[Medline].
  • Danforth DR, Arbogast LK, Mroueh J, et al: Dimeric inhibin: a direct marker of ovarian aging. Fertil Steril 1998 Jul; 70(1): 119-23[Medline].
  • Faddy MJ, Gosden RG, Gougeon A, et al: Accelerated disappearance of ovarian follicles in mid-life: implications for forecasting menopause. Hum Reprod 1992 Nov; 7(10): 1342-6[Medline].
  • Isaacs JD Jr, Lincoln SR, Cowan BD: Extended clomiphene citrate (CC) and prednisone for the treatment of chronic anovulation resistant to CC alone. Fertil Steril 1997 Apr; 67(4): 641-3[Medline].
  • Johnson NP, Mak W, Sowter MC: Surgical treatment for tubal disease in women due to undergo in vitro fertilisation. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2004; CD002125[Medline].
  • Kovacs GT, Newman GB, Henson GL: The postcoital test: what is normal? Br Med J 1978 Apr 1; 1(6116): 818[Medline].
  • Mitwally MF, Biljan MM, Casper RF: Pregnancy outcome after the use of an aromatase inhibitor for ovarian stimulation. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2005 Feb; 192(2): 381-6[Medline].
  • Navot D, Rosenwaks Z, Margalioth EJ: Prognostic assessment of female fecundity. Lancet 1987 Sep 19; 2(8560): 645-7[Medline].
  • Peters AJ, Lloyd RP, Coulam CB: Prevalence of out-of-phase endometrial biopsy specimens. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1992 Jun; 166(6 Pt 1): 1738-45; discussion 1745-6[Medline].
  • Petrozza JC: The Role of Diagnostic Laparoscopy in Evaluation of Infertility. Infertil Reprod Med Clin North Am 1997.
  • Schlaff WD, Hassiakos DK, Damewood MD, Rock JA: Neosalpingostomy for distal tubal obstruction: prognostic factors and impact of surgical technique. Fertil Steril 1990 Dec; 54(6): 984-90[Medline].
  • Stumpf PG, March CM: Febrile morbidity following hysterosalpingography: identification of risk factors and recommendations for prophylaxis. Fertil Steril 1980 May; 33(5): 487-92[Medline].
  • Tietze C: Reproductive span and rate of production among Hutterite women. Fertil Steril 1957; 8: 89.
  • Tiitinen A, Unkila-Kallio L, Halttunen M, Hyden-Granskog C: Impact of elective single embryo transfer on the twin pregnancy rate. Hum Reprod 2003 Jul; 18(7): 1449-53[Medline].
  • Watson A, Vandekerckhove P, Lilford R, et al: A meta-analysis of the therapeutic role of oil soluble contrast media at hysterosalpingography: a surprising result? Fertil Steril 1994 Mar; 61(3): 470-7[Medline].

Assisted Reproduction Technology excerpt