You are in: eMedicine Specialties > Urology > Erectile Dysfunction, Premature Ejaculation, and Sexual Disorders Erectile DysfunctionArticle Last Updated: Jan 15, 2008AUTHOR AND EDITOR INFORMATIONAuthor: Stanley A Brosman, MD, Clinical Professor, Department of Urology, University of California at Los Angeles Medical School Stanley A Brosman is a member of the following medical societies: Alpha Omega Alpha, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Association for Cancer Research, American Association for the Advancement of Science, American College of Surgeons, American Medical Association, American Society of Clinical Oncology, American Urological Association, Association of Clinical Research Professionals, International Society of Urological Pathology, Société Internationale d'Urologie (International Society of Urology), Society for Basic Urologic Research, Society of Surgical Oncology, Society of Urologic Oncology, and Western Section American Urological Association Editors: Martha K Terris, MD, FACS, Professor, Department of Surgery, Medical College of Georgia; Francisco Talavera, PharmD, PhD, Senior Pharmacy Editor, eMedicine; Mark Jeffrey Noble, MD, Consulting Staff, Urologic Institute, Cleveland Clinic Foundation; J Stuart Wolf, Jr, MD, FACS, David A Bloom Professor of Urology, Director, Division of Minimally Invasive Urology, Department of Urology, University of Michigan Medical Center; Stephen W Leslie, MD, FACS, Founder and Medical Director of the Lorain Kidney Stone Research Center, Clinical Assistant Professor, Department of Urology, Medical College of Ohio Author and Editor Disclosure Synonyms and related keywords: erectile dysfunction, impotence, sexual dysfunction, male sexual dysfunction, ED, premature ejaculation, ejaculatory dysfunction, hypoactive sexual desire, erection, ejaculation, penis disorder, sexual disorder, penile curvature, Peyronie disease, Peyronie's disease, organic impotence, psychogenic impotence, sildenafil, Viagra, vardenafil, Levitra, tadalafil, Cialis, tadenafil, psychosocial sexual disorder, sexual health, flaccidity, flaccid penis, erectile difficulty, diminished libido, diabetes, hypertension, coronary artery disease, neurologic disorders, depression, pelvic surgery, prostate surgery, benign prostatic hyperplasia, sleep apnea, low levels of high-density lipoproteins, insomnia, lethargy, posttraumatic stress syndrome, posttraumatic stress disorder, cigarette smoking, atherosclerosis, peripheral vascular disease, myocardial infarction, radiation therapy to the pelvis, radiation therapy to the prostate, radical prostatectomy, scleroderma, dyslipidemia, idiopathic hemachromatosis, liver cirrhosis, renal failure, epilepsy, Alzheimer disease, Guillain-Barré syndrome, multiple sclerosis, stroke, chronic obstructivepulmonary disease, hyperthyroidism, hypothyroidism, hypogonadism, epispadias, priapism, widower syndrome, performance anxiety, malnutrition, zinc deficiency, sickle cell anemia, leukemias, aortoiliac bypass, aortofemoral bypass, proctocolectomy, transurethral resection of the prostate, cryosurgery of the prostate, cystectomy, antiulcer agents, cholesterol-lowering agents, 5-alpha reductase inhibitors, antihypertensives, antipsychotics, antidepressants INTRODUCTIONBackgroundSexual health and function are important determinants of quality of life. Disorders such as erectile dysfunction (ED) and female sexual dysfunction are becoming increasingly more important as a result of the aging US population and newer therapies. Because this subject is discussed widely in the media, men and women of all ages are seeking guidance in an effort to improve their relationships and experience satisfying sexual lives. This review article discusses the physiology of the normal erection and the pathophysiology, etiology, and treatment of ED. For additional resources, visit Erectile Dysfunction. Successful treatment of sexual dysfunction has been demonstrated to improve sexual intimacy and satisfaction, improve sexual aspects of quality of life, improve overall quality of life, and relieve symptoms of depression. Although this article focuses primarily on ED in males, one must remember that the sexual partner plays an integral role. If successful and effective management is to be achieved, the evaluation and discussion of any intervention should include both partners. The Process of Care Model for the Evaluation and Treatment of Erectile Dysfunction has been developed to advance new guidelines for the diagnosis and management of ED in the primary care and multidisciplinary setting. The model was developed under the auspices of the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School. The chairman of the group of experts who prepared the guidelines was Raymond Rosen, MD. The key components of this model are (1) a rational approach to diagnosis and treatment, (2) emphasis on clinical history taking and a focused examination, (3) specialized testing and referral in predefined situations, (4) a step-wise management approach with ranking of treatment options, and (5) incorporation of patient and partner needs and preferences in the decision-making process. An alternative model is the patient goal-oriented approach as suggested by Tom Lue, MD, in which a minimum of testing is performed. The patient and his partner express a preference for reasonable and appropriate treatment options and work with the physician to implement this plan. The availability of three phosphodiesterase-5 (PDE-5) inhibitors, ie, sildenafil (Viagra), vardenafil (Levitra), and tadalafil (Cialis), has permanently altered the medical management of ED. Many patients no longer expect or are willing to undergo a long evaluation and testing process to obtain a better understanding of their sexual problem, and they are less likely to involve their partner in a discussion of their sexual relationship with the physician. Because of intense mass-media marketing efforts, the sexual expectations of men have risen to new highs and the attitude that something is wrong with a man if he does not achieve a perfect erection is prevalent. Men who have no difficulty obtaining erections are taking these PDE-5 inhibitor medications in the belief that their sexual performance will be enhanced and the opportunity for multiple orgasms will increase. Their medications are often obtained by a phone call to their doctor or even over the Internet with minimal or no physician contact at all. The misuse and overuse of these remarkable medications are likely to have a major impact on how sexual performance and sexual relationships are viewed. Physiology of normal erections Penile erections involve an integration of complex physiologic processes involving the CNS, peripheral nervous system, and hormonal and vascular systems. Any abnormality involving these systems, whether from medication or disease, has a significant impact on the ability to develop and sustain an erection, ejaculate, and experience orgasm. Tumescence, the vascular filling of the cavernous bodies, relies on neural and hormonal mechanisms operating at various levels of the neural axis. This is unique among visceral functions because it requires central neurological input. Andersson summarized some of the information related to the pathways involved in erectile function.1 The degree of contraction of corpus cavernosal smooth muscle determines the functional state of the penis. The balance between contraction and relaxation is controlled by central and peripheral factors that involve many transmitters and transmitter systems. At the cellular level, smooth muscle relaxation occurs following the release of acetylcholine from the parasympathetic nerves. The nerves and endothelium of sinusoids and vessels in the penis produce and release transmitters and modulators that control the contractile state of corporal smooth muscles. Although the membrane receptors play an important role, downstream signaling pathways are also important. The RhoA–Rho kinase pathway is involved in the regulation of cavernosal smooth muscle contraction. The nitric oxide (NO) pathway is of critical importance in the physiologic induction of erections. The drugs currently used to treat erectile dysfunction were developed as a result of experimental and clinical work that demonstrated that NO released from nerve endings relaxes the vascular and corporal smooth muscle cells of the penile arteries and trabeculae, resulting in an erection. NO is produced by the enzyme nitric oxide synthase (NOS). Three forms have been identified: nNOS, eNOS, and iNOS, which are produced by the genes NOS1 (nNOS), NOS2 (iNOS), and NOS3 (eNOS). This nomenclature is derived from the source of the original isolates. nNOS was found in neuronal tissue, iNOS was found in immunoactivated macrophage cell lines, and eNOS was found in vascular endothelium. All forms of NOS produce NO, but various factors trigger and regulate this process. NOS plays many roles, ranging from homeostasis to immune system regulation. These subtypes are not limited to the tissues from which they were first isolated. Each NOS subtype may play a different biological role in various tissues. nNOS and eNOS are considered constitutive forms because they share biochemical features. They are calcium-dependent, they require calmodulin and reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate for catalytic activity, and they are competitively inhibited by arginine derivatives. These 2 subtypes use the biochemical pathway that targets cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP). They are involved in the regulation of neurotransmission and blood flow, respectively. iNOS is considered inducible because it is calcium-independent. iNOS is induced by the inflammatory process, in which it is involved in the production nitrogenous amines. This subtype has been shown to be involved in the carcinogenic process, leading to transitional cell carcinoma. All 3 NOS subtypes produce NO by oxidation of L-arginine, which is one of the basic amino acids. It circulates in the blood and is found in cells synthesized from the urea cycle or from oral ingestion. The concentration of L-arginine within the cell far exceeds that in the circulation. Inside the cell, NOS catalyzes the oxidation of L-arginine to NO and L-citrulline. Endogenous blockers of this pathway have been identified. The gaseous NO that is produced acts as a neurotransmitter or paracrine messenger. Its biologic half-life is only 5 seconds. NO may act within the cell or diffuse and interact with nearby target cells. Potential ways to alter NO levels include the following:
Increasing evidence indicates that NO acts centrally to modulate sexual behavior and to exert its effects on the penis. NO is thought to act in the medial preoptic area and the paraventricular nucleus. Injection of nitric acid synthase inhibitors prevents the erectile response in rats that have been given erectogenic agents. Factors that mediate contraction in the penis include noradrenaline, endothelin-1, neuropeptide Y, prostanoids, angiotensin II, and other factors not yet identified. Factors that mediate relaxation include acetylcholine, NO, vasoactive intestinal polypeptide, pituitary adenylyl cyclase–activating peptide, calcitonin gene–related peptide, adrenomedullin, adenosine triphosphate, and adenosine prostanoids. Sexual behavior involves the participation of autonomic and somatic nerves and the integration of numerous spinal and supraspinal sites in the CNS. The penile portion of the process that leads to erections represents only a single component. The ability to achieve and maintain a full erection also depends on the status of the peripheral nerves, integrity of the vascular supply, and biochemical events within the corpora. Erections occur in response to tactile, olfactory, and visual stimuli. The hypothalamic and limbic pathways play an important role in the integration and control of reproductive and sexual functions. The medial preoptic center, paraventricular nucleus, and anterior hypothalamic regions modulate erections and coordinate autonomic events associated with sexual responses. Afferent information is assessed in the forebrain and relayed to the hypothalamus. The efferent pathways from the hypothalamus enter the medial forebrain bundle and project caudally near the lateral part of the substantia nigra into the midbrain tegmental region. Several pathways have been described to explain how information travels from the hypothalamus to the sacral autonomic centers. One pathway travels from the dorsomedial hypothalamus through the dorsal and central gray matter, descends to the locus ceruleus, and projects ventrally in the mesencephalic reticular formation. Input from the brain is conveyed through the dorsal spinal columns to the thoracolumbar and sacral autonomic nuclei. The primary nerve fibers to the penis are from the dorsal nerve of the penis, a branch of the pudendal nerve. The cavernosal nerves are a part of the autonomic nervous system and incorporate both sympathetic and parasympathetic fibers. They travel posterolaterally along the prostate and enter the corpora cavernosa and corpus spongiosum to regulate blood flow during erection and detumescence. The dorsal somatic nerves are also branches of the pudendal nerves. They are primarily responsible for penile sensation. Sexual stimulation causes the release of neurotransmitters from the cavernosal nerve endings and relaxation factors from the endothelial cells that line the sinusoids. NOS produces NO from arginine. This, in turn, produces other muscle-relaxing chemicals such as cGMP and cyclic adenosine monophosphate, which work via calcium channel and protein kinase mechanisms. This results in the relaxation of smooth muscle in the arteries and arterioles that supply the erectile tissue, producing a dramatic increase in penile blood flow. Relaxation of the sinusoidal smooth muscle increases its compliance, facilitating rapid filling and expansion (40-52% of the corpora cavernosa tissue is composed of smooth muscle cells). The venules beneath the rigid tunica albuginea are compressed, resulting in near-total occlusion of venous outflow. These events produce an erection with an intracavernosal pressure of 100 mm Hg. Additional sexual stimulation initiates the bulbocavernous reflex. The ischiocavernous muscles forcefully compress the base of the blood-filled corpora cavernosa, and the penis reaches full erection and hardness when intracavernous pressure reaches 200 mm Hg or more. At this pressure, both the inflow and outflow of blood temporarily cease. Detumescence results from the cessation of neurotransmitter release, the breakdown of second messengers by phosphodiesterases, and sympathetic nerve excitation during ejaculation. Contraction of the trabecular smooth muscle reopens the venous channels, allowing the blood to be expelled, which results in flaccidity. Pathophysiology of erectile dysfunction ED is essentially a vascular disease. It is often associated with other vascular diseases and conditions such as diabetes, hypertension, and coronary artery disease. Other conditions associated with ED include neurologic disorders, endocrinopathies, benign prostatic hyperplasia, and depression. Conditions associated with reduced nerve and endothelium function, such as aging, hypertension, smoking, hypercholesterolemia, and diabetes, alter the balance between contraction and relaxation factors. These conditions cause circulatory and structural changes in penile tissues, resulting in arterial insufficiency and defective smooth muscle relaxation. In some patients, sexual dysfunction may be the presenting symptom of these disorders. Additionally, ED is often an adverse effect of many commonly prescribed medications. Some psychotropic drugs and antihypertensive agents are associated with ED. Trauma that affects the neurologic or vascular components can also lead to ED. Men with severe Peyronie disease, an inflammatory vasculitis, may have enough scar tissue in the corpora to impede blood flow. Men with sleep disorders commonly experience ED. Another important consideration is the hormonal status of the patient. Hypogonadism that results in low testosterone levels adversely affects libido and erectile function. Hypothyroidism is a very rare cause of ED. Most patients with ED have multiple etiological factors; thus, assessing how much each is contributing to the problem is difficult. Because most men with ED have an organic cause, a thorough evaluation is necessary to correctly identify the specific etiology in any given individual. FrequencyUnited StatesSexual dysfunction is highly prevalent in men and women. In the Massachusetts Male Aging Study (MMAS), a community-based survey of men aged 40-70 years, 52% of the respondents reported some degree of erectile difficulty. Complete ED, defined as (1) the total inability to obtain or maintain an erection during sexual stimulation and (2) the absence of nocturnal erections, occurred in 10% of the respondents. Lesser degrees of mild and moderate ED occurred in 17% and 25% of responders, respectively. In the National Health and Social Life Survey, a nationally representative probability sample of men and women aged 18-59 years, 10.4% of men reported being unable to achieve or maintain an erection during the past year. This has a striking correlation to the proportion of men in the MMAS who reported complete ED. Both studies noted a strong correlation with age. Although the rate of mild ED in the MMAS remained constant (17%) in men aged 40-70 years, the number of men reporting moderate ED doubled (17-34%) and the number of men reporting complete ED tripled (5-15%). Extrapolating the MMAS data to the American population, an estimated 18-30 million men are affected by ED. Other male sexual dysfunctions, such as premature ejaculation and hypoactive sexual desire, are also highly prevalent. The National Health and Social Life Survey found that 28.5% of men aged 18-59 years reported premature ejaculation and 15.8% lacked sexual interest during the past year. An additional 17% reported anxiety about sexual performance, and 8.1% had a lack of pleasure in sex. Long-term predictions based on an aging population and an increase in risk factors (eg, hypertension, diabetes, vascular disease, pelvic and prostate surgery, benign prostatic hyperplasia, lower urinary tract symptoms) suggest a large increase in the number of men with ED. Also, the prevalence of ED is underestimated because physicians frequently do not question their patients about this disorder. InternationalStudies conducted around the world report similar risk factors and similar prevalence rates for ED. AgeAll studies demonstrate a strong association with age, even when data are adjusted for the confounding effects of other risk factors. The independent association with aging suggests that vascular changes in the arteries and sinusoids of the corpora cavernosae, similar to those found elsewhere in the body, are contributing factors. Other risk factors associated with aging include depression, sleep apnea, and low levels of high-density lipoproteins. CLINICALHistoryTaking the patient's history is informative to the physician and is an opportunity to educate the patient. Adequate time must be set aside for a full interview and to conduct a physical examination. Even clinicians who are not comfortable dealing with ED should inquire into this important aspect of the patient's health. A simple way to do this is simply ask, "How's your sex life? Everything working all right?" This type of inquiry should elicit a clear, quick, direct "Everything's fine" from the patient. Any other response or even just a delay in answering should suggest potential ED in that patient.
Physical
CausesThe etiology of ED is usually multifactorial. Organic, physiologic, endocrine, and psychogenic factors are involved in the ability to obtain and maintain erections. In general, ED is divided into organic and psychogenic impotence, but most men with organic etiologies usually have an associated psychogenic component. Almost any disease may affect erectile function by altering the nervous, vascular, or hormonal systems. Various diseases may produce changes in the smooth muscle tissue of the corpora cavernosa or influence the patient's psychologic mood and behavior. Pure psychogenic ED is an uncommon disorder, although most ED was once attributed to psychological factors. Diabetes is a well-recognized risk factor, with approximately 50% of diabetic men experiencing ED. The etiology of ED in diabetic men probably involves both vascular and neurogenic mechanisms. Evidence indicates that establishing good glycemic control can minimize this risk. Cigarette smoking has been shown to be an independent risk factor. In studies evaluating more than 6000 men, the risk of developing ED increased by a factor of 1.5 Mental health disorders, particularly depression, are likely to affect sexual performance. The MMAS data indicate an odds ratio of 1.82. Other associated factors, both cognitive and behavioral, may contribute. Also, ED alone can induce depression. The new oral agents have been shown to be effective for men who develop depression following prostatectomy. Cosgrove et al have reported a higher rate of sexual dysfunction in veterans with posttraumatic stress syndrome than in those veterans who did not develop this problem.3 The domains on the IIEF questionnaire that demonstrated the most change included overall sexual satisfaction and erectile function. This study suggests that regardless of etiology, men with posttraumatic stress syndrome should be evaluated and treated if they have sexual dysfunction. A sedentary lifestyle is a contributing factor to ED. Exercise has a beneficial effect on the cardiovascular system, and some data from the MMAS indicate that men who exercise regularly have a lower risk of ED. However, Goldstein et al reported an increased risk of ED in men who rode a bicycle for long periods.4 Therefore, the type of exercise may be important. The MMAS study also showed an inverse correlation between ED risk and high-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels but no effect from elevated total cholesterol levels. Another study involving male subjects aged 45-54 years found a correlation with abnormal high-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels but also found a correlation with elevated total cholesterol levels. The MMAS study had a preponderance of older men. Vascular diseases account for nearly half of all cases of ED in men older than 50 years. Vascular diseases include atherosclerosis, peripheral vascular disease, myocardial infarction, and arterial hypertension. Vascular damage may accompany radiation therapy to the pelvis and prostate in the treatment of prostatic cancer. In this situation, both the blood vessels and the nerves to the penis may be affected. Radiation damage to the crura of the penis, which are quite susceptible to radiation damage, can induce ED. The radiation oncologist must take precautions to avoid treating this area. Data indicate that 50% of men undergoing radiation therapy lose erectile function within 5 years after completing therapy. Fortunately, some of these men tend to respond to one of the PDE-5 inhibitors. Prostatic surgery for benign prostatic hyperplasia has been documented to be associated with ED in 10-20% of men. This is thought to be related to nerve damage from cautery. Newer procedures such as microwave, laser, or radiofrequency ablation have rarely been associated with ED. Radical prostatectomy for the treatment of prostate cancer poses a significant risk of ED. A number of factors are associated with the chance of preserving erectile function. If both nerves that course on the lateral edges of the prostate can be saved, the chance of maintaining erectile function is reasonable. This depends on the age of the patient. Men younger than 60 years have a 75-80% chance of preserving potency, but men older than 70 years have only a 10-15% chance. Sural nerve grafts are used by some surgeons. Following surgery, one of the PDE-5 inhibitors, such as sildenafil, vardenafil, or tadalafil, is frequently used to assist in the recovery of erectile function. Trauma to the pelvic blood vessels and nerves is another potential etiologic factor in the development of ED. Bicycle riding for long periods has been implicated as an etiologic factor by causing vascular and nerve injury. Some of the newer bicycle seats have been designed to diminish pressure on the perineum. Diseases associated with ED are summarized as follows:
DIFFERENTIALSAbdominal Trauma, Blunt Abdominal Trauma, Penetrating Abdominal Vascular Injuries Atherosclerosis Cirrhosis Cystectomy, Partial Cystectomy, Radical Depression Diabetes Mellitus, Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus, Type 2 Hemochromatosis Hypertension Hypertension, Malignant Hypertensive Heart Disease Hyperthyroidism Hypopituitarism (Panhypopituitarism) Hypothyroidism Myocardial Infarction Myocardial Ischemia Myocardial Rupture Nonbacterial Prostatitis Peripheral Arterial Occlusive Disease Peyronie Disease Priapism Prostate Cancer: Biology, Diagnosis, Pathology, Staging, and Natural History Prostate Cancer: Brachytherapy (Radioactive Seed Implantation Therapy) Prostate Cancer: External Beam Radiation Therapy Prostate Cancer: Management of Localized Disease Prostate Cancer: Metastatic and Advanced Disease Prostate Cancer: Neoadjuvant Androgen Deprivation Prostate Cancer: Nutrition Prostate Cancer: Radical Perineal Prostatectomy Prostate Cancer: Radical Retropubic Prostatectomy Prostate Hyperplasia, Benign Prostatitis, Bacterial Prostatitis, Tuberculous Renovascular Hypertension Scleroderma Sickle Cell Anemia
|
| Medication | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Hormonal (testosterone) therapy | No surgery required Painless Simple May restore sexual desire If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Patches now available Inexpensive | Useful only in the few patients with abnormal hormone levels Need to take medications regularly Significant adverse effects (eg, fluid retention, liver damage) Limited effectiveness |
| Vasodilators (nitroglycerine) | Safe No surgery required Painless May use treatment only when desired If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Inexpensive | Condom use required No reports on long-term use Possibly common adverse effects (eg, headaches) Lack of scientific studies on effectiveness Very high failure rate Very limited effectiveness |
| Yohimbine (Yocon) | Safe No surgery required Painless Adverse effects uncommon May increase sexual desire If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Success rate of 20-25% Inexpensive | Need to take medication every day No reports on long-term use Adverse effects, including nervousness, headache, dizziness, and nausea Failure rate of 75-80% Limited effectiveness |
| Pentoxifylline (Trental) | Safe No surgery required Painless Adverse effects uncommon If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Success rate of 50% in selected patients Inexpensive | Need to take medication every day No reports on long-term use Adverse effects, including headache, dizziness, and stomach upset May only help with marginal penile blood Failure rate of 50% |
| Trazodone (Desyrel) | Safe No surgery required Painless Adverse effects uncommon May improve success and reduce adverse effects of yohimbine If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Estimated success rate of 25% Inexpensive | Need to take medication every day No reports proving benefit No reports on long-term use Adverse effects, including lethargy and drowsiness Optimal dosage unknown Failure rate of 75% Limited effectiveness |
| Penile injection therapy | No surgery required Usually painless May use treatment only when desired Newer medications may reduce risks Easily hidden and transportable Refrigeration not required If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Success rate of 70-75% Highly effective Inexpensive | Requires injections directly into the penis Risk of infection, bruises, pain, and permanent scarring inside the penis Possible painful permanent erection (ie, priapism) No completely acceptable medication currently available Optimal combination of drugs not known Lacks formal FDA† approval (except for prostaglandin [ie, Caverject, Edex]) May not be covered by some insurance companies Cannot be used by patients on MAOIs* Usually not effective in patients with blood flow problems or vascular disease |
| Intraurethral pellet therapy (MUSE) | No surgery required Painless May use treatment only when desired Easily hidden and transportable If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Maximum usage up to twice daily No needles, injections, or scarring Approved by FDA Success rate of 45% Reasonably effective Inexpensive | Pellet must be inserted directly into penis through urethral opening Requires refrigeration Mild occasional burning or discomfort (experienced by approximately one third of patients) Possible priapism (rare <1%) Can cause mild dizziness, faintness, or low blood pressure Only 4 dosages are available May require a tension ring or penile tourniquet for best results |
| External vacuum therapy | Safe No surgery required Painless May use treatment only when desired May improve natural erections in some patients If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Success rate of 75-85% Highly effective Inexpensive | Requires some manual dexterity and strength Not easily hidden Somewhat bulky to transport Removing tension ring within 30 minutes recommended Tension ring necessary to maintain erection Possibly uncomfortable ejaculation May need to interrupt foreplay Proper tension ring size crucial for best results Requires practice |
*Monoamine oxidase inhibitors
†US Food and Drug Administration
A comparison of satisfaction rates and ED in subjects treated with sildenafil, intracavernous PGE1 (alprostadil), and penile implant surgery was performed by Rajpurkar and Dhabuwala in 138 men with ED. This was a nonrandomized study in which all subjects were initially offered sildenafil. The mean follow-up was 19.54 months, and questionnaires were used to obtain the data. Their conclusions were that men with a penile implant had significantly better erectile function and satisfaction.
The development of future medical options will emphasize the restoration of physiologic function. A better understanding of the molecular biology of ED will allow the development of new classes of agents. Research involving gene therapy is beginning to show promise.
One such research area has involved the use of the angiogenic growth factor and endothelial cell mitogen, vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF). This is produced by vascular smooth muscle, endothelial, and inflammatory cells. VEGF increases the production of nitric oxide, which improves endothelial function and blood flow in chronic ischemic disorders.
The direct intracavernosal injection of recombinant VEGF protein or adenoviral VEGF that contains plasmids have shown dramatic results based on cavernosography findings in animal models with arteriogenic, venogenic, and neural forms of ED. Burchardt et al identified VEGF 165 as the predominant isoform of the corpora cavernosa, as well as a novel splice variant.7 Although VEGF is a potent and important vascular regulator, it probably acts together with other vascular factors. Although a single-agent VEGF is unlikely to ever be used as monotherapy for ED, this represents an important step in understanding the normal and abnormal vascular physiology associated with ED.
A small number of healthy young men have developed ED as a result of trauma to the pelvic arteries. Revascularization procedures such as rotating the epigastric artery, or even smaller vessels, into the corpora have been attempted. The long-term results have been marginal.
Men who have difficulty maintaining erections as a result of venous leaks occasionally may benefit from a surgical procedure to eliminate much of the venous outflow. While initial enthusiasm for this and other surgical approaches was significant, this type of surgery has become rare because of a lack of long-term efficacy.
Penile implants
In the past, the placement of prosthetic devices within the corpora was the only effective therapy for men with organic ED. Now, this is the last option considered, even though more than 90% of men with an implant would recommend the procedure to their friends and relatives.
Implants are usually used for men in whom other therapies have failed or in those who require penile reconstructions. Men who have had a radical prostatectomy for prostate cancer and in whom a nerve-sparing procedure was not performed or was not successful often do not respond to oral PDE-5 inhibitors, and these men are good candidates for an implant. The same is true for men treated with radiation therapy, although more of these men tend to respond to oral agents. Additionally, some patients experience increased sexual satisfaction with the combined use of an implant and an oral PD5 inhibitor.
Before selecting this form of management, the patient and his sexual partner should be counseled regarding the benefits and risks of this procedure.
Two types of devices are available, a semirigid and a multicomponent inflatable system. With the semirigid prosthesis, two matching cylinders are implanted into the corpora cavernosa. These devices provide enough rigidity for penetration and rarely break. The major drawbacks are the cosmetic appearance of the penis, which remains semi-erect at all times, the need for surgery, and the destruction of the natural erectile mechanism when the prosthesis is implanted.
The inflatable devices consist of two Silastic or Bioflex cylinders inserted into the corpora cavernosa, a pump placed in the scrotum to inflate the cylinders, and a reservoir that is contained either within the cylinders or in a separate reservoir placed beneath the fascia of the lower abdomen. The inflatable prosthesis generally remains functional for 7-10 years before a replacement may be necessary. Improvements in these devices have resulted in a failure rate of less than 10%. Complications include infections in 2% of patients, erosion of the device through the urethra or skin in 2% of patients, and painful erections in 1% of patients. A newer antibiotic-coated device has further reduced the infection rate.
Patient acceptance of these devices is very high, with nearly 100% of the patients expressing satisfaction. Part of this enthusiasm is related to the failure of other therapies and the highly motivated patient population.
Table 2. Types of Surgical Therapies for ED
| Treatment | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Semirigid or malleable rod implants | Simple surgery Relatively few complications No moving parts Least expensive implant Success rate of 70-80% Highly effective | Constant erection at all times May be difficult to conceal Does not increase width of penis Risk of infection Permanently alters or may injure erection bodies Most likely implant to cause pain or erode through skin If unsuccessful, interferes with other treatments |
| Fully inflatable implants | Mimics natural process of rigidity-flaccidity Patient controls state of erection Natural appearance No concealment problems Increases width of penis when activated Success rate of 70-80% Highly effective | Relatively high rate of mechanical failure Risk of infection Most expensive implant Permanently alters or may injure erection bodies If unsuccessful, interferes with other treatments |
| Self-contained inflatable unitary implants | Mimics natural process of rigidity-flaccidity Patient controls state of erection Natural appearance No concealment problems Simpler surgery than fully inflatable prosthesis Success rate of 70-80% Highly effective | Sometimes difficult to activate the inflatable device Does not increase width of penis Mechanical breakdowns possible Long-term results not available Risk of infection Relatively expensive Permanently alters or may injure erection bodies If unsuccessful, interferes with other treatments |
| Vascular reconstructive surgery | Restores natural erections when successful Natural appearance No implant required If unsuccessful, does not interfere with other treatments Overall success rate of 40-50% Moderately effective | Most technically difficult surgery Only 50% of patients are potential candidates Extensive testing required Risk of infection, scar tissue formation with distortion of the penis, and painful erections May cause shortening or numbness of the penis Long-term results not available Relatively high relapse rate Very expensive |
Therapeutic options in managing erectile dysfunction
Currently, any man who wishes to have erectile function can do so regardless of the etiology of the problem. Many therapeutic options are available, and the task of the physician is to help the patient seek the best solution. Finding a trained and understanding physician who is willing to take the time to understand the patient's problem is the first step in identifying which therapeutic option will ultimately be most appropriate and successful.
Sexual counseling is the most important part of the treatment for patients with sexual problems. Many professional sexual counselors are skilled in working with patients, but the primary care physician, the urologist, and the gynecologist also serve in this capacity to some degree. These are usually the first professionals to learn about the problem, and they often have to extract the information about the sexual problem from the patient.
Men are frequently reluctant to discuss their sexual problems and need to be specifically asked. Opening a dialogue allows the clinician to begin the investigation or refer the patient to a consultant. Regardless of any subsequent therapy the patient may receive, the emotional aspects of the disorder must be addressed. Ideally, the couple should be involved in the counseling, but, even when this is not possible, the time spent may help resolve or at least clarify the problem certainly helps in deciding which of the other options would be most beneficial and appropriate.
Psychological care
Regardless of the etiology of ED, a psychological component is almost always associated with this disorder. The ability to achieve erection is intimately connected to a man's self-esteem and sense of worth. Pure psychogenic ED is generally evident when a man reports that he has normal erections some of the time but is unable to achieve or to main